The DOL’s fiduciary rule faces another legal challenge

The DOL’s fiduciary rule faces another legal challenge
A coalition of trade associations including the Insured Retirement Institute, ACLI, and NAIFA has filed a civil suit against the contentious Retirement Security rule.
MAY 24, 2024

A coalition of insurance trade associations has filed a lawsuit against the US Department of Labor (DOL), seeking to overturn a regulation they argue limits consumer choice in financial professionals and restricts access to retirement products that offer protected lifetime income.

The plaintiffs in the civil lawsuit include the American Council of Life Insurers, the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors, and the Insured Retirement Institute. They collectively criticized the DOL's fiduciary standard, which they say imposes undue restrictions on nearly all financial professionals who sell retirement products.

In their legal filing, the associations asserted that the DOL’s fiduciary-only regulation is fundamentally flawed and unconstitutional. They argued that it mirrors the DOL's 2016 rule, which was previously struck down by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals.

"The legal action we are taking today comes after careful deliberation on what is in the best interest of the retirement savers we serve," the coalition said in a joint statement.

The lawsuit contends that the regulation overreaches the DOL's authority, calling it “arbitrary” and “capricious” as it ignores federal and state standards already in place for financial professionals working with retirement savers. "

“Our filing makes a convincing case that the DOL’s fiduciary-only regulation suffers from the same legal defects as the DOL’s failed 2016 rule," the associations said, echoing an argument made in an earlier lawsuit against the new fiduciary rule advanced by another group.

Critics of the rule emphasize that it could have significant negative impacts on retirement savers. They cite the adverse effects of the 2016 regulation, which resulted in more than 10 million American workers' accounts with $900 billion in savings losing access to professional financial guidance.

"Despite claiming to help consumers, the rule, in fact, will be a catastrophe for retirement savers," the associations claimed in their filing.

"By imposing on sales recommendations substantial burdens deemed counterproductive by other regulators, and by redefining essentially all commercial relationships in the retirement savings marketplace as fiduciary, the rule will drastically and unreasonably raise the costs of assisting consumers," the filing read

The coalition further maintained that the new rule disregards the progress made by state policymakers in protecting consumers. Since 2020, 45 states have adopted the revised NAIC suitability in annuity transactions model, which aligns with the SEC’s Reg BI rule.

"The DOL’s fiduciary regulation upends this progress and undermines the expertise of state authorities who are responsible for overseeing annuities," the associations stated.

The lawsuit, filed in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, under the jurisdiction of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, contends that the regulation imposes significant fiduciary burdens on typical sales conversations.

It argues that the DOL rule violates the First Amendment rights of financial professionals and consumers alike by restricting each party’s ability to give or receive beneficial and truthful information about retirement products.

"Put simply, the department’s current rule suffers from the same key legal defects as the 2016 rule," the lawsuit argued. "It exceeds the agency’s statutory authority. It is the product of a rushed, outcome-oriented process. It is arbitrary and capricious in multiple respects."

Latest News

Financial advisors, what is your volatility game plan for client management?
Financial advisors, what is your volatility game plan for client management?

With targeted "comfort calls" and strategically automated follow-ups, advisors who leverage their CRM systems effectively can show up when clients need them most.

Trump eyes no taxes for Americans making less than $150k, says Lutnick
Trump eyes no taxes for Americans making less than $150k, says Lutnick

The plan could offer $24,000 in relief for some taxpayers, but experts warn of consequences.

No new trial for convicted GPB Capital executives
No new trial for convicted GPB Capital executives

"I've seen lots of denial in this business but this GPB thing take the cake," says one industry executive.

BlackRock-led deal for Panama Ports draws ire from China
BlackRock-led deal for Panama Ports draws ire from China

Commentary from state-owned publication blasts sale to investor consortium as "spineless groveling," denting Hong Kong-based firm's stock.

Gold soars past $3,000 as Trump turbocharges record rally
Gold soars past $3,000 as Trump turbocharges record rally

Higher interest rates and a strong US dollar, which traditionally act as headwinds, haven't deterred market-stung investors from seeking refuge in the yellow metal.

SPONSORED Beyond the all-in-one: Why specialization is key in wealth tech

In an industry of broad solutions, firms like intelliflo prove 'you just need tools that play well together'

SPONSORED Record growth: Interval funds emerge as key players in alternative investments

Blue Vault Alts Summit highlights the role of liquidity-focused funds in reshaping advisor strategies