Time for a new 401(k) model?

Automatic features of the 401(k) have improved savings opportunities for millions can workers over the past few years, but more could be done now and no new legislation is needed.
MAY 21, 2012
Mark Iwry, senior advisor to the Secretary of the Treasury for retirement policy, acknowledges that automatic 401(k) features have gone a long way to improve retirement saving opportunities for American workers. He dubbed the widespread use of automatic enrollment of new employees and default investment options such as target-date or balanced funds or managed accounts "401(k) 2.0". But why stop there? "We could move to a 3.0 model that's more robust -- without additional legislation and without a material increase in cost to employers," he said during a panel discussion of proposed retirement plan innovations sponsored by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Commerce in Washington this week. Rather than settling for the standard 3% default rate for the initial salary deferral of new employees who are automatically enrolled in their company 401(k) plan, Iwry suggested starting at a higher level, perhaps 5 or 6%. And instead of limiting auto enrollment to new employees, why not expand it to existing employees who are not participating in the retirement plan? He also recommended lifting the cap that some plan sponsors place on automatic escalation arrangements that are designed to boost employees' 401(k) contributions by 1% or 2% for each year. Instead of setting an arbitrary contribution cap of 6% or 10% of salary, Iwry suggested that the annual maximum contribution limit--currently $17,000 ($22,500 for those age 50 or older) -- - be the only restriction 401(k) plans impose on employee salary deferrals. Iwry also suggested that a “401(k) 3.0” could have a variety of other “best practices” to encourage saving. These might include more effective employer matching contributions (including matching formulas that encourage higher employee contributions, even if at a lower cents-on-the-dollar rate, or that offer lower-wage workers a higher rate of match). In addition, he would like to see shorter eligibility waiting periods; broader coverage of part-time workers; expanded acceptance of rollover contributions; and corporate cultures that encourage employees to contribute at least 10% of pay. Employers should help employees understand how much retirement income their current account balance would create and offer retirement income payout options from 401(k) plans. "These are things we can move on right now. We don't have to wait," he said. One of the biggest challenges to future retirement security is to increase the number of Americans who have access to a retirement plan at work. Tens of millions of workers don't, particularly those employed by small businesses. The Obama administration has proposed to make workplace saving accessible to those workers by providing a tax credit for small businesses with more than 10 workers that don't sponsor a plan. Those businesses would be required to automatically enroll employees in salary- reduction contributions to an IRA. Employees could opt out and employers would make no contributions of their own. "To the extent that there would be any administrative cost to employers, the tax credit would defray that cost," Iwry said. And given that the tax credit would offset any costs, Iwry said, "It would not be fair to call this a ‘mandate'."

Latest News

Maryland bars advisor over charging excessive fees to clients
Maryland bars advisor over charging excessive fees to clients

Blue Anchor Capital Management and Pickett also purchased “highly aggressive and volatile” securities, according to the order.

Wave of SEC appointments signals regulatory shift with implications for financial advisors
Wave of SEC appointments signals regulatory shift with implications for financial advisors

Reshuffle provides strong indication of where the regulator's priorities now lie.

US insurers want to take a larger slice of the retirement market through the RIA channel
US insurers want to take a larger slice of the retirement market through the RIA channel

Goldman Sachs Asset Management report reveals sharpened focus on annuities.

Why DA Davidson's wealth vice chairman still follows his dad's investment advice
Why DA Davidson's wealth vice chairman still follows his dad's investment advice

Ahead of Father's Day, InvestmentNews speaks with Andrew Crowell.

401(k) participants seek advice, but few turn to financial advisors
401(k) participants seek advice, but few turn to financial advisors

Cerulli research finds nearly two-thirds of active retirement plan participants are unadvised, opening a potential engagement opportunity.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today’s choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave