Unions could be 'next frontier' for retirement plan litigation

New excessive-fee suit alleges multiemployer plan covering more than 27,000 participants breached its duties under retirement law.
DEC 01, 2017

Defined contribution plans for labor unions appear to be the newest target of retirement plan litigation, following the filing of a lawsuit that legal experts say is likely the first to attack a union for excessive fees. The lawsuit, Ybarra et al v. Board of Trustees of Supplemental Income Trust Fund et al, alleges fiduciaries of the Supplemental Income 401(k) Plan, a $922 million multiemployer plan covering more than 27,000 participants, breached their duties under retirement law by offering expensive mutual funds and record-keeping services that eroded investors' savings. Plaintiffs Cesario Serrato and Felipe Ybarra, respectively current and former employees of San Bernardino Steel, filed the suit Thursday in California district court. The lawsuit comes as excessive-fee cases have proliferated in recent years, and have expanded their tentacles into different corners of the retirement market. "It could be the next frontier," said Duane Thompson, senior policy analyst at fi360 Inc., a fiduciary consulting firm. The case echoes those of many other lawsuits that since 2006 have alleged employers allowed their workers to pay excessive fees for plan services such as investment management and administration. Early cases involved large, private-sector corporations sponsoring multibillion-dollar 401(k) plans, including Lockheed Martin Corp., General Dynamics and International Paper. Not only have those cases begun to move downstream to smaller corporate retirement plans, they've also targeted different sorts of institutions. Jerry Schlichter, the attorney credited with pioneering the initial tranche of excessive-fee suits, last year sued roughly a dozen private universities over their 403(b) plans. Plaintiffs also have gone after financial services companies for alleged self-dealing, saying the firms profited at employees' expense by filling their own retirement plans with proprietary investment funds. There's also been a raft of litigation against employers over their employee stock ownership plans, as well as religiously affiliated hospitals sponsoring defined benefit plans. "If you're trying to make a living as plaintiff's counsel, you need to find new targets that have substantial monies where you can make claims," said John Utz, an employee benefits and executive compensation attorney at Utz & Lattan. "Last year we saw the 403(b)s were new ground to plow. [Labor unions] were another area that hadn't yet been touched." Multiemployer DC plans have a "different feel" from other types of DC plans, Mr. Utz said. There's a "natural tension" in the operation of union plans because they're overseen by a split between management and rank-and-file workers, he said, whereas those of the typical DC plan most often are overseen just by management. "Plaintiffs' counsel might feel there are some differences there that are exploitable," Mr. Utz said.

Latest News

What advisors need to know about SECURE 2.0’s impact on retirement income planning
What advisors need to know about SECURE 2.0’s impact on retirement income planning

Catch-up contributions, required minimum distributions, and 529 plans are just some of the areas the Biden-ratified legislation touches.

EToro to tokenize US stocks on Ethereum network for 24/7 trading
EToro to tokenize US stocks on Ethereum network for 24/7 trading

Following a similar move by Robinhood, the online investing platform said it will also offer 24/5 trading initially with a menu of 100 US-listed stocks and ETFs.

GTCR to acquire FMG Suite, expanding its wealth tech portfolio
GTCR to acquire FMG Suite, expanding its wealth tech portfolio

The private equity giant will support the advisor tech marketing firm in boosting its AI capabilities and scaling its enterprise relationships.

$29B Lido Advisors expands in Utah with Olympus Wealth Management
$29B Lido Advisors expands in Utah with Olympus Wealth Management

The privately backed RIA's newest partner firm brings $850 million in assets while giving it a new foothold in the Salt Lake City region.

Annuities hit new $223B high in H1 2025, LIMRA says
Annuities hit new $223B high in H1 2025, LIMRA says

The latest preliminary data show $117 billion in second-quarter sales, but hints of a slowdown are emerging.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.