Vanguard? Fidelity? Retirees clueless about sellers of retirement income products

They're not up to speed about the products themselves, either
FEB 19, 2010
Retired persons and those contemplating retirement are basically at sea when it comes to choosing retirement income products — or the providers of those products. And that confusion presents a massive opportunity for advisers and financial services firms. A new study, released today by Cogent Research LLC, found that retirees and pre-retirees mostly rely on a combination of certificates of deposit and laddered bonds to ensure a steady stream of income during retirement. Variable annuities were the third-most-popular retirement income vehicle, but investors are clearly unsure what these products actually are. Indeed, fewer than one in six investors said that they are very familiar with retirement income products. For instance, investors don't seem to understand that variable annuities can provide steady income. When asked if they rely on variable annuities for retirement, about a third responded affirmatively, but only 15% said they actually own any type of retirement income product. “Education seems to be in order,” wrote the authors of the study, Carrie Merrick, project director, and Cogent principal and co-founder Christy White. The survey also revealed that no single type of advisory firm, or specific brand name, has an edge in the market. When retirees were asked which firm is the best at helping investors manage and invest income during retirement, no vendor stood out. Fidelity Investments topped the list, cited by 9% of the respondents. About 7% of the polled retirees named The Vanguard Group Inc. By comparison, fully 27% of the retirees said they don't know which firm is the best for retirement income products. Brokerage firms and mutual fund companies were cited more often than insurance companies as the most appropriate kind of firm for providing retirement income products, however. “There's a real lack of knowledge,” Ms. White said in an interview. “Advisers have a great opportunity to step in” and educate. “No one's rallying around any one brand,” she added. “I found that astonishing, and a real reflection of the fact that investors don't know — they really don't know.” Ms. Merrick and Ms. White suggested in their report that financial services firms can better appeal to retirees and pre-retirees by marketing retirement income products as a “guaranteed paycheck.” This is the “dominant terminology and idea that has been accepted by retirees and pre-retirees, and resonates with them most,” they wrote. Emphasizing financial stability is also a good idea, they suggested. “This will help them believe you will deliver on your promise of a guaranteed paycheck in the future.” The Cogent survey was conducted over the Internet in December and captured the views of 961 affluent investors 55 and older who have at least $100,000 in investible assets.

Latest News

Cerulli: Advisors struggle to turn 401(k) savers into wealth clients
Cerulli: Advisors struggle to turn 401(k) savers into wealth clients

Just over 10% of advisors' wealth clients come from defined contribution plans, as capacity, data and technology gaps block the bridge to wealth

Alto to buy Forge Trust from Schwab in self-directed IRA push
Alto to buy Forge Trust from Schwab in self-directed IRA push

Deal creates a $20B-plus custody platform for private market investing in IRAs, months after Schwab closed its Forge Global purchase

Wall Street bonanza! The Street on track to hit a record $90 billion in profits: Report
Wall Street bonanza! The Street on track to hit a record $90 billion in profits: Report

Despite the good times, advisors should tread carefully, said one veteran industry executive.

Aspen Standard Wealth buys $1B Louisiana RIA Cullen Investment Group
Aspen Standard Wealth buys $1B Louisiana RIA Cullen Investment Group

Cullen marks the fourth firm the New York-based RIA aggregator has bought in 2026 as deal volume heads for a record year.

Strategy before technology: Establishing the foundation for measurable AI value
Strategy before technology: Establishing the foundation for measurable AI value

The quality of AI ROI measurement depends on pre-deployment decisions around business outcomes, leadership alignment, and establishing trusted information, among other factors.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.

SPONSORED In the Age of AI, Trust Becomes the Advisor's Greatest Asset

As AI makes financial information more accessible than ever, Lana Hock explains why human judgment, trust, and empathy remain the qualities clients value most in a financial advisor