Wells Fargo wouldn't be the first to push proprietary products on 401(k) plan participants

Let's not fool ourselves that the conduct allegedly being investigated at Wells Fargo is limited to one firm.
APR 27, 2018

The disclosure of an alleged Labor Department investigation of Wells Fargo sales practices — including those in its retirement-plan services division — is sure to raise a few eyebrows, but should this sort of thing really be a revelation to anyone in the 401(k) industry? The Wall Street Journal reported Thursday that the Department of Labor is looking into, among other things, "whether Wells Fargo's retirement-plan services unit pressed account holders to buy in-house funds, generating more revenue to the bank." The article suggests the DOL is investigating potential violations of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, which prohibits fiduciaries from self-dealing. Regardless of what Wells Fargo may or may not have done, let's not fool ourselves. Pushing proprietary products — both in 401(k) plans and to participants rolling over 401(k) money into an individual retirement account — is something that many record keepers have engaged in for quite some time. It's just that companies were largely able to escape scrutiny prior to the DOL fiduciary rule coming into effect, because they had broad latitude to engage in such conduct without breaking the rules. Advisers and other observers often say that it's not the actual record keeping that's profitable to retirement-plan providers; the record-keeping platform is more of a distribution arm to get participants to (hopefully) invest in their funds. Record keepers also benefit from interaction with participants — often via a call center — looking to roll over their 401(k) money when they retire or change jobs; the hope is such interactions will lead to money flowing to in-house IRA funds. It's not a coincidence that most of the big record keepers are companies that sell mutual funds or insurance products like stable-value funds — think Fidelity Investments, Vanguard Group, Voya Financial Inc. and Transamerica Retirement Solutions. Prior to the fiduciary rule coming into effect in June, many record keepers would more aggressively try steering plans and participants to adopt proprietary funds. "It's something a lot of record keepers did pre-rule," said Ellen Lander, an adviser at Renaissance Benefit Advisors Group. Prior to the rule, which raises investment advice standards in retirement accounts, record keepers generally held themselves out as non-fiduciary service providers to avoid the associated fiduciary liability. "If the record keeper isn't a fiduciary, they don't have a legal obligation to say their products are more expensive or they don't perform as well," Ms. Lander said. If there is a DOL investigation, it's not clear if it is into conduct before or after the DOL fiduciary rule went into effect. Wells Fargo is currently conducting an independent investigation of its Wealth and Investment Management business, which includes its retirement business, on instructions from the Department of Justice. When asked to comment, spokeswoman Leslie Ingberg said Wells Fargo's top priority is rebuilding trust with stakeholders. "We are committed to thorough reviews of Wealth and Investment Management, per our 10-K disclosures, to their full conclusion," she said. "We are making significant progress in our work to identify and fix any issues, make things right, and build a better, stronger company." If I were a betting man, my money would be on an examination of Wells Fargo's conduct prior to the rule, since the DOL has said it's not enforcing the fiduciary regulation at this time. In that case, the investigation would likely hinge on whether Wells Fargo was, in the DOL's view, making recommendations as a fiduciary to invest in proprietary products during the more lax pre-rule period. For what it's worth, many record keepers have changed their conduct in light of the fiduciary rule, which makes it much more challenging for record keepers to steer participants into proprietary investments. Some are actively embracing a fiduciary role in their client interactions. I'm not trying to paint a view that all record keepers are evil, greedy corporations consistently looking to make a buck at the expense of plans and their participants. But, regardless of the outcome of the investigation, we shouldn't be blind to the fact that proprietary funds have for a long time been, and will continue to be, important to record keepers' livelihood.

Latest News

No succession plan? No worries. Just practice in place
No succession plan? No worries. Just practice in place

While industry statistics pointing to a succession crisis can cause alarm, advisor-owners should be free to consider a middle path between staying solo and catching the surging wave of M&A.

Research highlights growing need for personalized retirement solutions as investors age
Research highlights growing need for personalized retirement solutions as investors age

New joint research by T. Rowe Price, MIT, and Stanford University finds more diverse asset allocations among older participants.

Advisor moves: RIA Farther hails Q2 recruiting record, Raymond James nabs $300M team from Edward Jones
Advisor moves: RIA Farther hails Q2 recruiting record, Raymond James nabs $300M team from Edward Jones

With its asset pipeline bursting past $13 billion, Farther is looking to build more momentum with three new managing directors.

Insured Retirement Institute urges Labor Department to retain annuity safe harbor
Insured Retirement Institute urges Labor Department to retain annuity safe harbor

A Department of Labor proposal to scrap a regulatory provision under ERISA could create uncertainty for fiduciaries, the trade association argues.

LPL Financial sticking to its guns with retaining 90% of Commonwealth's financial advisors
LPL Financial sticking to its guns with retaining 90% of Commonwealth's financial advisors

"We continue to feel confident about our ability to capture 90%," LPL CEO Rich Steinmeier told analysts during the firm's 2nd quarter earnings call.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.