Advisers differ on whether in-house investment management is a plus

Brodeski says advisers should advise; Carson insists that it's possible to generate alpha.
FEB 03, 2014
To pick stocks or hire others to pick — that was the question that recently divided two successful financial advisers who were sharing business secrets with the profession. The ongoing debate among advisory firms about whether the asset management piece of wealth management is a commodity or an essential value that advisers deliver surfaced again at last week's TD Ameritrade Institutional national conference in Orlando, Fla. Brent Brodeski, chief executive of $3.8 billion Savant Capital Management, is in the camp which holds that investments themselves are a commodity. “We can pretend asset management is a differentiator, but what drives growth is when advisers advise,” Mr. Brodeski told about 100 advisers at a panel discussion on adviser growth secrets last Thursday. He said the key to building an advisory business is to drive toward “an extreme value proposition,” not the investment solution. Ron Carson, founder and chief executive of $4 billion Carson Wealth Management, disagreed. “It takes a lot of work, but you can generate positive alpha,” Mr. Carson said, referring to the extra value a portfolio manager can add to investment returns. He told advisers, however, that that doesn't mean a firm should have one person trying both to create client plans and do the investing piece. Advisers also should not try to distinguish themselves just by promoting their investment performance. “Don't let your performance define who you are,” Mr. Carson said. “Give yourself as many ways as you can to win.” Firms that outsource the investment management piece typically use turnkey asset management programs that combine research and other administration services like billing and portfolio management. Today about 20,757 financial advisers use 34 different TAMPs to manage about $147 billion in assets, according to research released in August 2013 from Tiburon Strategic Advisors. Other firms sell advisers just investment research.

Latest News

Trump says not necessary to fire Powell after getting Fed tour
Trump says not necessary to fire Powell after getting Fed tour

‘To do that is a big move, and I just don’t think it’s necessary,’ Trump says.

Vanilla locks in US patent for estate planning tech, strengthening advisor reach
Vanilla locks in US patent for estate planning tech, strengthening advisor reach

The wealth tech platform says its newly secured patent represents crucial advances in digitizing outdated manual processes.

Wealth managers weigh in on Trump's potential order to open 401(k) plans to alternatives
Wealth managers weigh in on Trump's potential order to open 401(k) plans to alternatives

Financial advisors offer their thoughts on the President's widely anticipated executive order to open retirement accounts to private market assets.

SEC: First Liberty misused fresh investor money in $140 million scheme
SEC: First Liberty misused fresh investor money in $140 million scheme

The SEC says First Liberty lured investors with high-yield promissory notes, then used fresh cash to cover defaults and interest owed to earlier investors.

SEC hits pause on Bitwise ETF offering broad crypto exposure
SEC hits pause on Bitwise ETF offering broad crypto exposure

The agency's decision to stay the approval process just hours after signing off highlights ongoing ambiguity for new crypto-focused ETF offerings.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.