Advisers should sound off on 401(k) plan advice

Most 401(k) plan participants need investment advice.
JUN 14, 2010
By  MFXFeeder
Most 401(k) plan participants need investment advice. Unfortunately, most will not pay for it, nor will most plan sponsors, especially in today's economic and business climate. The Labor Department estimates that individuals in 401(k) plans make investment errors that cost them between $5.5 billion and $10.9 billion annually. It estimates that the cost of such errors might be cut in half with investment advice. Of course, many plan participants could get advice from the brokers or investment advisers working with or for the fund companies that provide the funds used in the plans. But the current Labor Department, suspicious — along with many others — that such advice would be conflicted and self-serving, withdrew a proposed rule that would have allowed it. The department and other observers were concerned that the proposed rule did not adequately protect investors from advisers who recommend funds that most benefit their own personal income statements, not necessarily those that are most appropriate for plan participants. The agency appears to be on the right track in its proposal that would allow broker-related advisers to provide advice to 401(k) plans if they based the advice on third-party-provided computer-based models. But it has asked for comment on a number of questions regarding investment theory, investment performance, historical returns and the factors that should be acceptable in such models. Among other questions, the department asks: What investment theories are generally accepted, and what investment practices are consistent or inconsistent with such theories? Should the regulation specify such theories and require their application? Should the model specify a minimum number of years in performance data used in the models? Is a fund's past performance relative to the average for its asset class an appropriate criterion? Under what, if any, conditions would it be consistent with generally accepted investment theories and with consideration of fees to recommend a fund with superior past performance over an alternative fund in the same asset class with average performance but lower fees? Should the regulation specify such conditions? On what, if any, bases can a fund's superior past performance be demonstrated to derive not from chance but from factors that are likely to persist and continue to affect performance in the future? The last three questions appear to suggest that the Labor Department might require the models to include only index funds in their options. Whether or not it is appropriate to exclude actively managed funds from a model depends on how efficient the stock market really is. While some sectors of the market — large-cap stocks, for instance — appear efficiently priced most of the time, other sectors, notably small cap stocks and especially foreign small-caps, appear not to be. There is also the issue of whether the Labor Department should be endorsing constrained models (i.e., those limited to index funds). The department has asked for comment on these and a number of other questions before it makes its rule final. Financial planners and investment advisers should make their expert opinions known. Comments should be emailed to [email protected] (enter into subject line: 2010 investment advice proposed rule) or by using the Federal Rulemaking portal at regulations.gov.

Latest News

Devoe: record-breaking RIA M&A run led by private equity's consolidator comeback
Devoe: record-breaking RIA M&A run led by private equity's consolidator comeback

A drop in interest rates and easier access to capital has reignited appetite among private equity-backed consolidators, who accounted for 53% of RIA deals so far this year—their highest share since 2021 according to Devoe & Company'.

Fintech bytes: Advisor360, Nitrogen unveil AI updates for advisor productivity
Fintech bytes: Advisor360, Nitrogen unveil AI updates for advisor productivity

Also, Advisor CRM announces a new data integration partnership to ease the pain of client onboarding.

Bank of America, Morgan Stanley earnings roll despite roiled markets
Bank of America, Morgan Stanley earnings roll despite roiled markets

Meanwhile, Merrill Lynch intends to continue building its alternative investment platform for wealthy clients.

David Fischer of Independent Financial Group talks culture, future growth
David Fischer of Independent Financial Group talks culture, future growth

The co-founder of IFG discussed with InvestmentNews the unique opportunity that remaining independent offers to build a successful firm.

Wealth Consulting Group taps veterans from Envestnet, Emigrant Partners for new advisory board
Wealth Consulting Group taps veterans from Envestnet, Emigrant Partners for new advisory board

Three industry leaders will join the hybrid RIA's president and LPL alum, Andy Kalbaugh, to help guide its organic and merger-based growth strategy.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.