Binance accuses CFTC of overreach, wants charges dropped

Binance accuses CFTC of overreach, wants charges dropped
World's largest crypto exchange and its founder say the regulator's case is outside its remit and that its case is unsound.
JUL 28, 2023
By  Bloomberg

Binance Holdings Ltd., operator of the world’s largest crypto exchange, and its co-founder Changpeng Zhao asked a US federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit filed by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. 

Attorneys for Binance and Zhao — also known as CZ — submitted the motion on Thursday, arguing the regulator is overreaching and using theories relying on inconsistencies while also making unsound claims and irrelevant allegations.

“In this case, the CFTC seeks to regulate foreign individuals and corporations that reside and operate outside the United States — outstripping the limits of its statutory authority and treading on deep-rooted principles of comity with foreign sovereigns,” they wrote in the filing.

The CFTC sued the company and Zhao in March, alleging they took intentional steps to evade US laws — including deliberately allowing Americans to use the platform to buy and sell crypto derivatives despite Binance never registering. The agency also sued Samuel Lim, Binance’s former chief compliance officer, who also filed a motion to dismiss Thursday.

REGULATORY PRESSURE

Binance and its Chief Executive Officer Zhao have been fielding growing regulatory pressure around the world, emblematic of a clampdown on crypto after a rout in the market last year that triggered a series of major blowups.

While the platform remains dominant in crypto markets, its share of spot digital-asset trading volumes has declined in recent months. Earlier in July, billionaire Zhao sought to counter concerns about Binance’s outlook following the exits of executives who had been helping to navigate the regulatory crisis.

Zhao has previously said that the CFTC’s complaint “appears to contain an incomplete recitation of facts” and that he didn’t agree with “the characterization of many of the issues alleged in the complaint.”

Binance declined to comment further on Thursday’s submission. The CFTC didn’t immediately return a request for comment.

JURISDICTION QUESTIONED

The 49-page motion states that Zhao isn’t under US jurisdiction, because he resides in the United Arab Emirates.

“The CFTC’s failure to include allegations sufficient to establish personal jurisdiction requires dismissal,” the defendants’ lawyers wrote in the filing.

The motion claims that two incidents in which Zhao allegedly interacted by email with potential US users occurred “more than a year before Binance.com ever began offering the alleged derivatives products at issue.”

US regulators have said that Binance.com made it easy for American users to get onto the platform.

The US Securities & Exchange Commission last month accused Binance and Zhao of mishandling customer funds, misleading investors and regulators, and breaking securities rules. Binance has said that it intends to defend its platform “vigorously.”

Latest News

RIA moves: Arax extends Midwestern reach, Steward Partners debuts in Arizona
RIA moves: Arax extends Midwestern reach, Steward Partners debuts in Arizona

Arax acquires a boutique firm's $4 billion RIA business in Alabama as Steward Partners continues its Southwestern expansion.

In this hi-tech world of finance, JPMorgan has an old school strategy to woo HNWs
In this hi-tech world of finance, JPMorgan has an old school strategy to woo HNWs

Wealth management is a key focus for a new service tier.

5 best practices to brand your process & win more busines
5 best practices to brand your process & win more busines

Advisors can set their practice apart and win more business with a powerful graphic describing their unique business and value proposition.

Industry, financial experts sound off after DOL walks back crypto warning for 401(k)s
Industry, financial experts sound off after DOL walks back crypto warning for 401(k)s

The Labor Department's reversal from its 2022 guidance has drawn approval from crypto advocates – but fiduciaries must still mind their obligations.

Autopilot surges to $750M AUM, touts RIA growth as users copy Pelosi, Buffett trades
Autopilot surges to $750M AUM, touts RIA growth as users copy Pelosi, Buffett trades

With $750 million in assets and plans to hire a RIA Growth Lead, Autopilot is moving beyond retail to court advisors with separately managed accounts and integrations with RIA custodians such as Schwab and Fidelity.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave

SPONSORED The evolution of private credit

From direct lending to asset-based finance to commercial real estate debt.