CFA Institute's new framework aims to improve clarity for index investment products

CFA Institute's new framework aims to improve clarity for index investment products
It hopes to bring greater transparency and more effective communication.
AUG 02, 2024

Active decisions made by asset managers in the creation and maintenance of index-based products should be clear to investors. And the CFA Institute has developed a framework to help.

With innovations such as smart beta ETFs and direct indexing, the investment classification framework and policy recommendations for regulators and firms are designed to improve transparency, communication, and investor comprehension.

Under the framework, index-based strategies are explained to investors according to their level of active decision-making and indexing is on a spectrum beyond traditional market cap weighting, based on three dimensions of strategy, sources of returns, and level of discretion.

Rhodri Preece, CFA, senior head of research, CFA Institute, said that the notion of a simple bifurcation between active and passive investment products is outdated.  

“Index-based strategies are varied in their design features and involve different layers of active decision-making, dispelling the historical distinction between active and passive management,” he said. “As index-based products have proliferated, incorporating more complex features than market capitalization weighting, there is a need for greater transparency and improved investor comprehension of these strategies. This new framework intends to support investment advisers and end-investors through clearer disclosure and communication of the key features of index-based products.”

With improving disclosures for investors as a focus, the recommendations for investment firms include:

  • Educate and inform investors of the active decisions made throughout the investment process for index-based investments.
  • Communicate to investors about the decision-making processes involved in index fund creation, including security selection and weighting methodologies used in the creation of the investment product or strategy.
  • Provide prospective clients with access to more detailed information on index product features as part of the pre-sale product literature.

The framework and recommendations are available on the CFA Institute website.

Latest News

Investor accuses Canaras, U.S. Bank of hiding $50 million CLO loss
Investor accuses Canaras, U.S. Bank of hiding $50 million CLO loss

A trustee says it has no record of the investor now suing it for $50 million

New bill would let advisers unlock accredited investor status for clients
New bill would let advisers unlock accredited investor status for clients

Legislation seeks to loosen access to private markets to include professional advice from RIAs and broker-dealers, not just income or net worth.

More than a quarter of moms are planning to opt out of Trump accounts, survey finds
More than a quarter of moms are planning to opt out of Trump accounts, survey finds

"I just feel like I can get a lot further [by] opening a 529 account," said one respondent to the BabyCenter survey on Trump accounts.

IRA investors keep rushing toward lower-cost mutual funds
IRA investors keep rushing toward lower-cost mutual funds

New ICI research shows these retirement savers pay expense ratios nearly matching industrywide averages, extending years of fee declines

US household wealth grows more liquid than global peers
US household wealth grows more liquid than global peers

UBS data show American net worth is shifting from property to cash and funds faster than in seven other wealthy nations.

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income

SPONSORED Why direct indexing stopped being optional

Direct indexing is on pace to outgrow ETFs and mutual funds. Northern Trust's Ken Lassner explains why the advisors who get it wish they had started sooner.