Consumers increased online spend for Black Friday, physical shop sales more subdued

Consumers increased online spend for Black Friday, physical shop sales more subdued
Preliminary data reveals good start to holiday shopping season.
DEC 02, 2024

As Cyber Monday continues the holiday shopping season that escalated in the run up to Thanksgiving with a focus on Black Friday, what has consumer spending looked like and which retailers are the winners and losers?

Two sets of preliminary data suggest that shoppers were keen to spend but the desire for bargains and convenience means online retailers and those main street brands with strong online presence are likely to have benefited most from increased spending.

Mastercard Spending Pulse reveals a 3.4% year-on-year increase in US retail sales on Black Friday, not adjusted for inflation and covering both online and physical stores. Online saw an increase of almost 15% while online stores gained less than 1%.

“Black Friday was a good indicator of how the holiday season is positively shaping up,” said Michelle Meyer, chief economist, Mastercard Economics Institute. “Our real-time insights show that consumers are comfortably in the gift-giving spirit as price reductions and deals occur across sectors, supporting budgets for holiday shopping.”

Separate early data from in-store foot traffic analysts RetailNext also showed the challenge for physical stores with overall traffic down more than 3% year-over-year on Black Friday and down almost 1% on Saturday.

“While overall traffic remains subdued, we saw some notable reversals from trends observed throughout the year,” said Joe Shasteen, Global Head of Advanced Analytics at RetailNext.  “Footwear, which experienced year-over-year traffic declines in nearly every month of 2024, showed resilience during Black Friday weekend. Categories like Apparel, Footwear, and Jewelry saw notable traffic increases on Saturday, indicating that consumers are spreading out their purchases.”

One key factor though is the weather conditions in both the Midwest and Northeast, which will have put many shoppers off visiting stores and may have prompted additional online shopping.

CAUTIOUS SPENDING

The Mastercard research also highlights the strength of Jewelry, Electronics and Apparel, with the latter showing notable e-commerce growth.

But it also showed that, with finances still leading to cautious spending behavior, value has been a key consideration in the two weeks leading up to Black Friday weekend.

“Shoppers are making the most of seasonal deals and enjoying a balance of experiences spending and gifts for all loved ones,” said Steve Sadove, senior advisor for Mastercard and former CEO and Chairman of Saks Incorporated. “They're more strategic in their shopping though, prioritizing promotions that they believe hold the greatest value — opening their wallets, but with more intentional distribution.”

Latest News

Merrill lands four advisor teams as May recruiting data shows firm's two-way churn
Merrill lands four advisor teams as May recruiting data shows firm's two-way churn

Merrill's latest hires span Colorado to Louisiana, even as industry-wide recruiting data suggests the firm is losing almost as many advisors as it gains.

Fund manager sues Kandeo, alleges $100 million FinSocial loss
Fund manager sues Kandeo, alleges $100 million FinSocial loss

The $36 million buy allegedly hid inflated books and a $50 million diversion.

Advisor gets $200,000 from Ameriprise in 'emotional distress' lawsuit
Advisor gets $200,000 from Ameriprise in 'emotional distress' lawsuit

“An award citing emotional distress is very unusual,” an industry executive said.

Workplace financial education linked to stronger financial habits, but participation remains low
Workplace financial education linked to stronger financial habits, but participation remains low

New EBRI research found workers who participated in employer financial education reported higher confidence, literacy and financial satisfaction.

The rise of the super advisor: How AI is redefining competitive advantage in wealth management
The rise of the super advisor: How AI is redefining competitive advantage in wealth management

Beyond operational excellence, the winning advisors of the future are the ones who can reach across multiple disciplines without discarding specialist skills.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income