Despite contrasts, neither Donald Trump nor Hillary Clinton's tax plan challenges existing regime

A summary of the key components of the tax plans proposed by presidential candidates.
OCT 30, 2016
As with everything else surrounding the 2016 presidential election, there is a lot of uncertainty and hype when it comes to the potential impact on the U.S. tax regime. Of course, when it comes to tax reform, the devil is always in the details. The following summarizes the key components of the tax plans proposed by presidential candidates Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump.

BUSINESS TAXES

On the business tax front, Mr. Trump's proposal lowers the corporate tax rate to 15% (from a maximum 35%), while Ms. Clinton has not announced any plans to change the U.S. corporate tax rate from its existing levels. Ms. Clinton has proposed a tax on high-frequency trading (at a currently unspecified rate). Mr. Trump has proposed a one-time, 10% repatriation tax on all currently deferred overseas income that would allow U.S. entities to repatriate “trapped” foreign profits back to the country at a reduced rate. Despite the differences in rate proposals, neither plan revamps or changes the fundamental “worldwide” characteristic of the U.S. tax regime. Thus, under both plans, a U.S. corporation (or individual) would remain subject to U.S. tax on its worldwide income, albeit at potentially lower rates than currently in the event Mr. Trump's plan is enacted. As a result, neither plan eliminates the necessity of multiple returns, foreign-tax-credit calculations or U.S. reporting obligations that have significantly raised costs for U.S. businesses and individuals working overseas. Although Trump's plan to allow a lowered tax rate on repatriated income helps U.S. entities with overseas income, it should be remembered these profits have already been taxed overseas, so his proposal effectively lowers the rate on a second level of tax. Finally, neither candidate's plan appears to revise the existing foreign account reporting regime that has impacted the ability of U.S. businesses to work with foreign financial institutions.

INDIVIDUAL TAXES

On the individual side, Ms. Clinton plans to add a 4% surcharge to income over $5 million, while raising rates on medium-term capital gains (defined as investments held less than six years) to between 24.6% and 39.6% (the current rate for such gains would be 23.6%). 4%surcharge Hillary Clinton wants to add to incomes over $5 million Mr. Trump's plan lowers the highest marginal rate from 39.6% to 33% and establishes three tax brackets at rates of 12%, 25% and 33%. His plan also eliminates the 3.6% net investment income surtax, effectively reducing the maximum long-term capital gains rate to 20%. Both candidates have proposed taxing carried interest at ordinary income rates, as opposed to capital gains rates. Although these proposals could impact equity investment and formation activities, in Mr. Trump's case, the lower proposed ordinary income rates would lessen the effect on high-income investors. In Ms. Clinton's version, the combination of the existing ordinary income rate and the proposed 4% surcharge would mean the carried interest change is more likely to have an impact on potential investment and formation activities.

ESTATE TAX

Mr. Trump plans to eliminate the estate tax, while Ms. Clinton's plan increases the top estate tax rate to 45% and lowers the estate tax exclusion to $3.5 million. Her plan would increase the need for significant levels of estate planning — particularly for family farms and businesses where liquidity issues might arise upon a succession event. (Related read: Hillary Clinton-Donald Trump slugfest could permanently alter US politics: Horizon Investments' political strategist) Mr. Trump's plan would eliminate the need for complex estate planning and instead would allow small businesses to focus on succession planning from a business and operational standpoint. One unaddressed question relates to existing, proposed and future regulations. One would expect Ms. Clinton to follow the current trajectory of broad-reaching IRS regulations. To the extent that Mr. Trump limits additional regulations or the expansion of current regulations, his plan might again differ significantly from Ms. Clinton's. However, without any specific proposals, it is hard to determine as of yet. Joshua A. Ehrenfeld is a tax lawyer and partner at Burr & Forman.

Latest News

Social Security trustees see one less year in insolvency countdown, project shortfall to start 2034
Social Security trustees see one less year in insolvency countdown, project shortfall to start 2034

New report shows dimmed outlook for benefits to retirees and disabled Americans, creating further pressure for federal tax hikes or more borrowing.

NY Republican Stefanik presses SEC to probe Harvard bond sale
NY Republican Stefanik presses SEC to probe Harvard bond sale

Open letter to SEC Chair Paul Atkins questions whether the Ivy League university withheld material information prior to its $750 million taxable bond offering.

Ex-LPL leader re-emerges at The Wealth Consulting Group
Ex-LPL leader re-emerges at The Wealth Consulting Group

The Las Vegas-based hybrid RIA overseeing $8.8 billion in assets has named Andy Kalbaugh president to help scale its advisor platform.

Envestnet extends investment offerings with new alts model portfolios
Envestnet extends investment offerings with new alts model portfolios

The wealth tech giant – in collaboration with Fidelity, BlackRock, State Street, and Franklin Templeton – is offering its advisor and wealth firm users more ways to diversify.

Just as wealth industry M&A was picking up, economic uncertainty could kill it again
Just as wealth industry M&A was picking up, economic uncertainty could kill it again

Deal volume increased post-election but now caution has taken over.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave