Merrill Lynch will 'vigorously' take OpenArc breakaway dispute to FINRA arbitration

Merrill Lynch will 'vigorously' take OpenArc breakaway dispute to FINRA arbitration
OpenArc Corporate Advisory successfully fended off a temporary restraining order in Georgia, with the court ruling favoring the RIA's move to independence.
OCT 02, 2025

After a federal court judge in Georgia denied Merrill Lynch’s temporary restraining order request in a lawsuit against breakaway RIA team OpenArc Corporate Advisory, the wirehouse remains committed to pursuing further legal action regarding OpenArc’s departure. 

“The injunction hearing is only​ the first step in the litigation process. We look forward to vigorously pursuing this matter in arbitration and are confident that a FINRA panel will agree that the defendants engaged in a corporate raid and conspired to poach our employees and clients,” Merrill Lynch said in a statement to InvestmentNews.

Merrill’s lawsuit was against OpenArc as well as its new custodian Charles Schwab and investment bank Dynasty Financial Partners. Merrill accused the defendants of conspiring to run a “premeditated corporate raid” of the Atlanta-based OpenArc team, which managed $129 billion in assets at Merrill Lynch. In a Tuesday ruling, Judge Victoria Calvert in the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of Georgia denied Merrill’s request for injunctive relief and a restraining order.

“[Tuesday's] court decision is a watershed moment for the wealth management industry. It acknowledges the strength and sophistication of the independent movement,” Dynasty CEO Shirl Penney said in a statement. “The judge found no evidence to show that the protocol for broker recruitment was not followed. The Court also noted that OpenArc, Dynasty and Schwab acted in good faith.”

Penney has joined the board of directors at OpenArc, which took minority investment from Dynasty Financial Partners amid its wirehouse breakaway to go independent. “We will always stand for and advocate for client and advisor choice which is at the core of what the independent movement is all about,” Penney said. 

A spokesperson for Charles Schwab also shared the below statement following Tuesday’s court ruling.

“As we said in our filing, the allegations against Schwab were not facts but rather unfounded speculation. We are pleased that the Court agreed. We hold ourselves to the highest standards of integrity and our business practices are rooted in respect for individual choice and fair competition. And our unwavering commitment to our clients is our guiding priority.”

Latest News

Estate planning gaps leave families facing steep probate costs, new report finds
Estate planning gaps leave families facing steep probate costs, new report finds

With trillions of dollars set to change hands, new data suggests probate costs and delays are becoming a bigger factor in estate planning decisions.

Orion, RFG moves take aim at onboarding and transition speed
Orion, RFG moves take aim at onboarding and transition speed

Orion and RFG Advisory tackle account-opening delays with new updates as custodial integrations reshape how fast advisors can move client assets.

Corient adds $5B New York multi-family office Seven Bridges
Corient adds $5B New York multi-family office Seven Bridges

The deal extends the acquisitive mega-RIA's rapid 2026 expansion as industry consolidation hits record levels nationwide

Navigating the straight
Navigating the straight

As recent Middle East tensions put the Strait of Hormuz back in focus, a structured process with purpose can help protect investors against their natural self-sabotaging tendencies in choppy markets.

Commonwealth-affiliated Longwave hires from LPL-affiliated firm amid Pacific Northwest expansion
Commonwealth-affiliated Longwave hires from LPL-affiliated firm amid Pacific Northwest expansion

ESG-focused Longwave Financial, approaching $1B AUM, acquired Seattle-based MG Financial and hired a client services manager from an LPL-affiliated firm.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income