Profit forecasts are too high, says Morgan Stanley

Profit forecasts are too high, says Morgan Stanley
Wall Street strategist Michael Wilson says Q3 and Q4 earnings may disappoint.
OCT 23, 2023

The odds of a year-end rally in US stocks are fading as investors face a multitude of risks from elevated profit estimates to the Federal Reserve’s policy tightening, according to Morgan Stanley’s Michael Wilson.

The strategist — among the most bearish voices on US stocks — said he “would not be surprised” to see further declines in the S&P 500 with “earnings expectations likely too high for the fourth quarter and 2024, and policy tightening likely to be felt from both a monetary and fiscal standpoint.”

Wall Street analysts expect S&P 500 firms to post an earnings decline of 1.1% for the third quarter, before a rebound of 5.2% in the October-December period, according to data compiled by Bloomberg Intelligence. Forward 12-month estimates have also risen close to a record high.

Wilson’s pessimistic view has been somewhat vindicated, with the S&P 500 tracking its third straight monthly decline on worries of higher-for-longer interest rates. On Friday, the benchmark closed at 4,224 points, below its 200-day moving average for the first time since March. That’s considered a key technical support level and used by traders to assess whether the longer-term trend is up or down.

The combined outlook for earnings, valuations and policy means that the S&P 500 “will have a hard time” getting back above 4,300 to 4,400 points — which were previously considered levels of tactical support, Wilson said. The strategist has a year-end target of 3,900 — nearly 8% below current levels.

The chorus of Wall Street strategists warning about a subdued end to the year has grown in recent weeks as stocks also face renewed geopolitical risks. The macroeconomic uncertainty as well as US bond yields nearing 5% have overshadowed the third-quarter reporting season, causing S&P 500 constituents to increasingly move in unison. 

JPMorgan Chase & Co. strategist Mislav Matejka sees further pressure on global stocks from an expected strengthening in the dollar, he wrote in a note dated Oct. 23. 

At RBC Capital Markets LLC, strategist Lori Calvasina also said the “outlook has become cloudier and we don’t think the pause in the S&P 500 rally is done yet.” Additionally, large-cap growth stocks are ripe for near-term declines as they’ve become “over owned and overvalued,” while balance sheet concerns, rising bond yields and economic gloom are hitting small-cap firms, she said. 

“The broader market, the growth trade and the small-cap trade are unlikely to find their footing again until the recent surge in bond yields comes to an end,” Calvasina wrote in a note.

Latest News

Diamonds that never existed: SEC says Lugano co-founder booked fake sales
Diamonds that never existed: SEC says Lugano co-founder booked fake sales

The SEC says the payouts came from later investors, and the numbers never added up

SEC alleges barred planner steered clients into tax-lien fraud
SEC alleges barred planner steered clients into tax-lien fraud

The SEC says he doubted the tax liens were real - and kept selling them to clients

Bank of America executive fatally stabbed in Times Square
Bank of America executive fatally stabbed in Times Square

Erin Piacenti, a vice president at Bank of America, was killed in a random attack in Times Square on Monday.

Wealth Enhancement expands in Virginia with Richmond-area RIA deal
Wealth Enhancement expands in Virginia with Richmond-area RIA deal

Minneapolis-based mega-RIA adds a $376 million hybrid RIA from Raymond James as its own $7 billion sale process reportedly plays out in the background.

Merit Financial names first chief technology officer as dealmaking pace continues
Merit Financial names first chief technology officer as dealmaking pace continues

Atlanta-based RIA taps former LPL executive John Rajes to unify systems as the firm looks to build on its 61-acquisition growth record.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income