RIAs moving to fees — but will clients move with them?

RIAs moving to fees — but will clients move with them?
Clear explanation will help ease fears, says analyst; still, some clients reluctant to pay for advice
AUG 15, 2011
As financial advisers rebuild from the 2007 market downturn, more are switching from commission-only business models to a mix of fees and commissions — despite suggestions that clients are resistant to paying a fee for financial advice. According to a research report by researcher Aite Group LLC, independent registered investment advisers and online brokerage firms have been the market share winners over the last two years, with online discount brokerages such as The Charles Schwab Corp. and Fidelity Investments increasing client assets by 50% as investors have embraced do-it-yourself investing. RIAs, who typically work on fees and commissions or solely on fees, also have seen above-average growth of client assets of 21% over the last two years, with much of the growth coming at the expense of traditional commission-based wirehouses. Those outfits are still 8% below their 2007 asset peak. The Aite report seemingly flies in the face of an investor survey this year by Cerulli Associates Inc. that asked investors if they prefer fees or commissions. About half said they prefer commissions, versus 27% who said they would opt for a fee-based pricing model. Another 18% prefer retainers, and 8% want hourly fees. The researcher said that fees rub investors the wrong way, at least until the benefits are explained. The apparent mismatch between advisers' moving to fees against the wishes of clients isn't so clear-cut, said Sophie Schmitt, a research analyst at Aite and one of the report's authors. Some of it “depends on how it is explained” to investors, Ms. Schmitt said. “Some may not really understand the difference between fee- and commission-based charges.” She said that many investors mistakenly believe that commissions are a one-time event, when they sometimes pay trailing commissions for years. For investors who conduct few trades, commission-based brokers may make more sense, but many have sought other options over the past few years, she said. Investors with account sizes below the typical adviser account may find discount online brokers a cheaper way to go, which helps account for their asset growth over the last two years, she said. Others feel that their investment needs are simple enough to manage at a discount broker. And some investors were disillusioned by their investment returns during the 2007 market downturn, when adviser-managed accounts didn't necessarily perform better than the overall market. Under those circumstances, “some investors said, ‘Why pay for advice?'” Ms. Schmitt said. The big wirehouses saw their brands tarnished during the crisis, which drove some customers away, she said. “These firms were being written about every day as not acting in the clients' best interests,” she said. Aite's report was based on an online survey of 438 financial advisers in the first quarter, as well as publicly available information and interviews with firm executives. At the end of 2010, the combined brokerage and advisory industry in the U.S. handled $13.5 trillion in client assets, just below the year-end 2007 level of $13.6 trillion, according to Aite. Around 460,000 financial advisers manage client funds, with wirehouses Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, Wells Fargo Advisors LLC and UBS Financial Services Inc. dominating the market, with the average wirehouse adviser managing just under $100 million, for a 38% market share of client assets. Retail brokerages manage $2.2 trillion, or 16%; non-wirehouse self-clearing retail brokerages manage $2.03 trillion, or 15%; independent registered investment advisers manage $1.55 trillion, or 11%; and self-directed online brokers manage $2.54 trillion, or 19%. (Click on the following link to see what top RIAs regard as their single greatest management challenge) A lot of investor money moved after the 2007 financial crisis, amid an exodus of wirehouse brokers to independent brokers such as LPL Financial and Ameriprise Financial Inc. and others or to independent RIA firms. Online brokerage firms such as Fidelity Investments, Charles Schwab and others gained the most at 50% between the end of 2008 to 2010. Independent RIAs and other self-clearing retail-brokerage firms surpassed their 2007 asset levels by 21% and 16%, respectively, while wirehouses assets are down 8%.

Latest News

NASAA moves to let state RIAs use client testimonials, aligning with SEC rule
NASAA moves to let state RIAs use client testimonials, aligning with SEC rule

A new proposal could end the ban on promoting client reviews in states like California and Connecticut, giving state-registered advisors a level playing field with their SEC-registered peers.

Could 401(k) plan participants gain from guided personalization?
Could 401(k) plan participants gain from guided personalization?

Morningstar research data show improved retirement trajectories for self-directors and allocators placed in managed accounts.

UBS sees a net loss of 111 financial advisors in the Americas during the second quarter
UBS sees a net loss of 111 financial advisors in the Americas during the second quarter

Some in the industry say that more UBS financial advisors this year will be heading for the exits.

JPMorgan reopens fight with fintechs, crypto over fees for customer data
JPMorgan reopens fight with fintechs, crypto over fees for customer data

The Wall Street giant has blasted data middlemen as digital freeloaders, but tech firms and consumer advocates are pushing back.

The average retiree is facing $173K in health care costs, Fidelity says
The average retiree is facing $173K in health care costs, Fidelity says

Research reveals a 4% year-on-year increase in expenses that one in five Americans, including one-quarter of Gen Xers, say they have not planned for.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.