SIFMA: Replace 'fiduciary duty' with 'universal standard of care'

Terms such as “fiduciary duty” and “suitability” contribute to investor confusion, and they should be replaced by a “universal standard of care” for brokers, says SIFMA.
MAR 10, 2009
By  Bloomberg
Terms such as “fiduciary duty” and “suitability” contribute to investor confusion, and they should be replaced by a “universal standard of care” for brokers and investment advisers, Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association president and chief executive Tim Ryan today told the Senate Banking Committee. In prepared testimony for a hearing on enhancing investor protection and regulating securities markets, he noted that a 2007 report written by the Rand Corp. of Santa Monica, Calif., for the Securities and Exchange Commission found that investors were confused by the two different sets of regulatory standards. Investment advisers are held to a fiduciary standard, which requires greater disclosure of possible conflicts of interest, while brokers are required to make product recommendations that are suitable for their clients. “Rather than perpetuating an obsolete regulatory regime, SIFMA [of New York and Washington] recommends the adoption of a universal standard of care that avoids the use of labels that tend to confuse the investing public and expresses, in plain English, the fundamental principles of fair dealing that individual investors can expect from all of their financial services provides,” Mr. Ryan said in his testimony. His statement amounts to a call for abandoning the fiduciary standard, said David Tittsworth, executive director and executive vice president of the Investment Adviser Association of Washington, which represents SEC-registered investment advisory firms. “This is saying eliminate fiduciary duty and let’s have a universal standard of care,” he said. “We think it would be a grave mistake to go to a lower standard of care. Fiduciary duty should be extended to everyone who gives investment advice, not eliminated or watered down,” Mr. Tittsworth said. Investment advisory groups, including the Financial Planning Association, the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors and the Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards Inc. have also called for requiring all financial advisers to come under fiduciary standards.

Latest News

Married retirees could be in for an $18,100 Social Security cut by 2032, CRFB says
Married retirees could be in for an $18,100 Social Security cut by 2032, CRFB says

A new analysis finds long-running fiscal woes coupled with impacts from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act stand to erode the major pillar for retirement income planning.

SEC bars New Jersey advisor after $9.9M fraud against Gold Star families
SEC bars New Jersey advisor after $9.9M fraud against Gold Star families

Caz Craffy, whom the Department of Justice hit with a 12-year prison term last year for defrauding grieving military families, has been officially exiled from the securities agency.

Navigating the great wealth transfer: Are advisors ready for both waves?
Navigating the great wealth transfer: Are advisors ready for both waves?

After years or decades spent building deep relationships with clients, experienced advisors' attention and intention must turn toward their spouses, children, and future generations.

UBS Financial loses another investor lawsuit involving Tesla stock
UBS Financial loses another investor lawsuit involving Tesla stock

The customer’s UBS financial advisor allegedly mishandled an options strategy called a collar, according to the client’s attorney.

Trump's one big beautiful bill reshapes charitable giving for donors and advisors
Trump's one big beautiful bill reshapes charitable giving for donors and advisors

An expansion to a 2017 TCJA provision, a permanent increase to the standard deduction, and additional incentives for non-itemizers add new twists to the donate-or-wait decision.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.