Why is SIPC covering Madoff investors?

Some broker-dealer executives who are now paying increased fees to the Securities Investor Protection Corp. are wondering why it is paying out on claims of investors victimized by Bernie Madoff.
AUG 07, 2009
Some broker-dealer executives who are now paying increased fees to the Securities Investor Protection Corp. are wondering why it is paying out on claims of investors victimized by Bernie Madoff. Those higher SIPC bills that brokerage firms are paying are the result of $231 million in payouts to Madoff victims that have been approved by the SIPC. And yet, in the wake of the Madoff scandal, officials of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. of New York and Washington have claimed that Finra, which regulates broker-dealers, had no authority over Madoff's investment advisory business, where the fraud occurred. What's more, no securities ever were purchased for Madoff customers. That has led industry observers to question why SIPC is covering Madoff's clients, since SIPC covers only broker-dealers. Under the statute that created the SIPC, a customer is defined as anyone who has deposited cash with a broker-dealer for the purpose of purchasing securities. “There were no transactions and no securities, but [Mr. Madoff] told people he did [place trades], and took their money on that premise,” said Stephen Harbeck, president and chief executive of the Washington-based SIPC. “As long as customers deposit money for that [SIPC-]protected purpose, they're covered,” he said. “The fact that [Madoff was] registered as an investment adviser is simply irrelevant.” Industry lawyers, meanwhile, have disputed the claim that Finra had no jurisdiction over Madoff's money management business. Prior to 2006, when Madoff first registered as an advisory firm, his broker-dealer — Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC of New York — had to be using the “solely incidental exemption” from the Investment Advisers Act, said John Coffee, a professor at Columbia Law School in New York, during Congressional hearings on the Madoff affair last January. After 2006, Mr. Madoff's advisory firm was using his broker-dealer as a qualified custodian, Mr. Coffee testified, which put it “fully within [Finra's] jurisdiction.”

Latest News

Morgan Stanley faces Finra probe on client vetting, WSJ says
Morgan Stanley faces Finra probe on client vetting, WSJ says

Focus is reportedly on a three year period from 2021-2024.

Goldman Sachs sees trump’s baseline tariff rate rising to 15%
Goldman Sachs sees trump’s baseline tariff rate rising to 15%

But economists say inflation impact may come in lower than expected.

AI boom leads to record costs on US grid and call for new plants
AI boom leads to record costs on US grid and call for new plants

How fast-growing tech means higher bills for millions of Americans.

Wirehouse rolls out AI tools throughout its wealth management division
Wirehouse rolls out AI tools throughout its wealth management division

The firm is extending the use of tools to help boost productivity.

Gray divorce is on the rise, posing a risk to retirement security
Gray divorce is on the rise, posing a risk to retirement security

Older couples are more likely to split than in the past, stats show.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.