Fed review could be a hurdle for Morgan Stanley-ETrade union

Fed review could be a hurdle for Morgan Stanley-ETrade union
But little resistance to the deal is expected from regulators, policymakers
FEB 20, 2020

Morgan Stanley’s acquisition of ETrade Financial Corp. will have to pass muster with the Federal Reserve, but Washington experts foresee the union avoiding regulatory and political roadblocks.

With Morgan Stanley spearheading the $13 billion deal announced on Thursday, the transaction involves a globally significant financial institution, as defined by Financial Stability Board.

That designation for Morgan Stanley triggers a Fed review about whether the combined institution will affect systemic stability, according to Jaret Seiberg, managing director of the Cowen Washington Research Group.

“This is not going to be an easy deal to move through the Federal Reserve,” Mr. Seiberg wrote. “We believe Morgan Stanley had to informally run this transaction past regulators before announcing it. That is normal practice as it does not benefit financial stability for the Federal Reserve to reject bank mergers. This would suggest there is a path to approval.”

Mr. Seiberg predicted the Fed review would take until the end of the year.

Saule Omarova, a professor of law at Cornell University, said it is difficult to predict how regulators and legislators will react to the acquisition, but she said the odds are good it will not be stopped by Washington.

“Generally, it is difficult to imagine financial regulators going after Morgan Stanley based simply on the size of the new entity,” Ms. Omarova wrote in an email. “This kind of antitrust-type strictness has not been the norm among financial regulators, especially in recent years. Such a big deal is hardly happening without at least an implicit acquiescence or at least knowledge of the key regulators.”

Ms. Omarova added: “Politically, the company’s emphasis on expanding its gold-standard Wall Street asset management services to regular folks probably makes this merger more difficult to attack head-on. This deal lacks an intuitively graspable political salience that usually prompts a strong political reaction.”

Nonetheless, the Morgan Stanley-ETrade tie-up generated push back on Thursday from a liberal financial services organization.

“The last thing that our economy needs is for one of the 'Too Big to Fail' banks to get even bigger,” Graham Steele, a senior fellow at the American Economic Liberties Project, said in a statement. “This deal would allow one of Wall Street's biggest banks to accumulate even more market power, giving it more control over working people's retirement savings and deposits, and putting the public on the hook for even more potential risks. Any public official that is truly concerned about preserving competitive markets and preventing taxpayer bailouts must oppose this acquisition.”

But that kind of political opposition from an interest group may not gain traction in the capital.

“I don’t think anybody is worried this is going to give Morgan Stanley monopoly pricing power in the retail market,” said Tyler Gellasch, executive director of Healthy Markets, an investor trade group.

Mr. Gellasch, a former counsel at the Securities and Exchange Commission and a former Senate aide, said the lack of objections in Washington to Charles Schwab Corp.’s acquisition of TD Ameritrade is instructive when it comes to Morgan Stanley taking over ETrade.

“I thought Schwab buying TD Ameritrade would raise more concerns with regulators and policymakers,” he said. “I would expect even less resistance for this acquisition.”

Morgan Stanley’s swallowing up ETrade could be viewed two ways in terms of its impact on the Schwab-TD deal. On the one hand, it effectively removes ETrade as an independent competitor for servicing registered investment advisers.

But Mr. Seiberg says it could ensure approval for the Schwab-TDA deal.

“This might help Schwab’s acquisition of TD Ameritrade as a Morgan Stanley-backed ETrade may be seen as a stronger potential competitor,” he wrote. “It is worth watching if Morgan Stanley discusses plans for the custodial business for registered investment advisers, which we see as the key issue for Schwab.”

Latest News

The fight over the CFPB is just beginning
The fight over the CFPB is just beginning

Locked out of their offices and told to stay home, employees at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau have asked the courts to intervene as Elon Musk and Republican leaders move to shut down the agency that was established to protect people from predatory lending and financial scams.

Business-focused wealth tech RISR lands $8B Wealthcare Capital Management partnership
Business-focused wealth tech RISR lands $8B Wealthcare Capital Management partnership

Fintech platform interVal has also introduced a new feature to help advisors support entrepreneurial business owner clients better.

LPL boosts revenue potential with amped-up alts platform
LPL boosts revenue potential with amped-up alts platform

Along with greater revenue, alternative investments also carry risks, one industry lawyer noted.

How SageSpring Wealth Partners' next-gen strategy has fueled its success
How SageSpring Wealth Partners' next-gen strategy has fueled its success

President Jeff Dobyns unpacks the strategic power of mentorship, what makes an "ideal team player," and how the firm's 89 percent success rate has paid off for veteran advisors.

Powell heads for hot-seat hearings with ongoing pressure from Trump policies
Powell heads for hot-seat hearings with ongoing pressure from Trump policies

The Fed chair is in for some "hyper-charged" meetings, with legislators likely to raise questions on tariff threats and apparent steps to comply with anti-DEI orders.

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.

SPONSORED Why wealth advisors should care about the future of federal tax policy

Blue Vault features expert strategies to harness for maximum client advantage.