SEC charges advisor with failing to disclose annuity commissions

SEC charges advisor with failing to disclose annuity commissions
The attorney for Massachusetts-based Jeffrey Cutter fires back at SEC, saying the agency is 'flat out wrong' and accusing it of trying to 'get a toehold into regulating the insurance industry.'
MAR 20, 2023

The SEC has charged an investment advisor with failing to adequately disclose commissions and other payments he earned for recommending annuity purchases, a move that could signal stepped-up scrutiny of insurance products.

The Securities and Exchange Commission filed a lawsuit Friday in a Boston federal court against Jeffrey Cutter, accusing him of steering clients into fixed index annuities over other investment options because Cutter pocketed hefty commissions and received free marketing services from an organization that helped him pitch annuities.

The SEC said Cutter received an up-front commission of approximately 7% on the annuity’s total value for sales that occurred between at least 2014 and 2022, generating at least $9.3 million in commissions from the sale of 580 annuities to investment advisory clients.

The SEC also alleged that Cutter persuaded some clients to exchange annuities they held for new ones in order to generate more commission revenue for himself. Replacing clients’ annuities produced at least $974,497 in commissions and forced some clients to pay surrender charges.

In addition, Cutter received more than $1.1 million from marketing firms for his efforts to sell annuities.

The SEC alleged that Cutter failed to disclose his conflicts of interest in recommending the annuity sales, violating his fiduciary duty to his clients.

The SEC is seeking permanent injunctions, disgorgement of ill-gotten gains plus prejudgment interest and civil penalties against Cutter, who founded Cutter Financial Group in 2017.

“Time after time, Cutter switched clients out of annuity contracts he had previously sold them into new annuity contracts without adequately disclosing his financial incentive to recommend these switches, including the substantial up-front commissions he received from the insurance company and other third parties,” the SEC states in its complaint. “To perpetrate his scheme, Cutter made false statements to the insurance companies to effectuate the switches and generate a new round of commissions for himself.”

Cutter’s attorney, Ian Roffman, denied the SEC’s charges. Roffman said CFG has always disclosed to customers that it sells insurance products and receives compensation for the transactions. The firm follows insurance industry standard practices for sales and disclosures.

“The SEC is flat out wrong on the facts and the law,” Roffman, a partner at Nutter McClennen & Fish, said in a statement. “This case is about trying to hold CFG to a standard above and beyond what is required of the industry in terms of disclosure. It’s ultimately using CFG, a small family-run business, as a means to get a toehold into regulating the insurance industry.”

Cutter lives in Falmouth, Massachusetts. He and his wife own CFG as well as CutterInsure Inc., a corporate affiliate through which he sells insurance products to advisory clients. Cutter is a licensed insurance agent in Massachusetts.

The SEC case against Cutter shows that the agency is taking a closer look at the sales of insurance products that act like investments, said Leibel Sternbach, owner of Yields for You, a registered investment advisory firm.

“The difference between an investment vehicle and an insurance contract is getting murky,” Sternbach said. “Be prepared to treat any insurance sale as investment advice, not as an outside business activity. You’re held to the same fiduciary responsibilities. The lawsuit is proof [the SEC is] really going after annuities. They want really specific disclosures.”

Latest News

The hidden currency risk in global investing: what advisors need to know
The hidden currency risk in global investing: what advisors need to know

For those seeking international exposure amid economic uncertainty, understanding the impact of the US dollar's strength over other currencies is more important than ever.

CFP Board warns of tax "tipping point" as TCJA expiration puts financial plans at risk
CFP Board warns of tax "tipping point" as TCJA expiration puts financial plans at risk

With nearly nine in 10 seeing danger to clients' retirement income and legacy plans, among others, CFP professionals are urging strategic planning pivots and tax perks for advice-seekers.

Fed Day focus fades as Trump keeps stock markets watching
Fed Day focus fades as Trump keeps stock markets watching

As policymakers convene for their latest two-day meeting, investors are shifting their attention from elevated interest rates to growth concerns and tariff worries.

IRS eases off on some audits with retrenchments giving way to AI
IRS eases off on some audits with retrenchments giving way to AI

While he hasn't laid out a clear plan, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has gone on record touting "the great AI revolution" in improving the agency's tax collections and customer service.

More than three-quarters of advisors to embrace fee models by 2026, Cerulli says
More than three-quarters of advisors to embrace fee models by 2026, Cerulli says

Momentum continues for fee-based compensation as BD advisors ditch commissions and alternative compensation schemes emerge to lure diverse clientele.

SPONSORED Beyond the all-in-one: Why specialization is key in wealth tech

In an industry of broad solutions, firms like intelliflo prove 'you just need tools that play well together'

SPONSORED Record growth: Interval funds emerge as key players in alternative investments

Blue Vault Alts Summit highlights the role of liquidity-focused funds in reshaping advisor strategies