Wall Street fights over tab for audit-trail system

Wall Street fights over tab for audit-trail system
The cost of the new system was estimated at $500 million at the end of last year.
SEP 06, 2023

A long-standing fight over who should pay for an expansive market-surveillance system intensified Wednesday as the Securities and Exchange Commission stuck brokers with most of the bill.

The plan, approved by three of the five commissioners, faces stiff opposition from industry trade groups and heavyweight players like Citadel Securities and Virtu Financial Inc. Banks and others that act as brokers or asset managers have complained that they will face the bulk of the fees.

The system, known as the Consolidated Audit Trail, or CAT, is designed to track billions of daily equities and options trades a day. It’s intended to help the SEC catch manipulators and diagnose the causes of market turmoil. It has been billed, in part, as a response to the infamous May 2010 flash crash, one of the worst routs in stock market history.

Fees will vary depending on whether they’re assessed on equities, options or over-the-counter equities. They’re based on share volumes, though some industry groups have said a percentage of notional value would be a fairer way to assess the fees. The measure replaces an earlier method of calculating fees based on market share.

LONG DELAYS

SEC Chair Gary Gensler said the new fee plan is the result of years of work by exchanges and is “based upon significant engagement with market participants and the public.”

The SEC initially approved the creation of the database in 2012, but implementation was delayed by the pandemic as well squabbles among exchanges, banks and brokerages over security, infrastructure, funding and other issues.

The contours of the system were primarily drafted by exchange operators, including the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq Inc., that will also pay fees. The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. also provided input.

CAT COSTS

The Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, the trade group representing brokers, filed new comments on Tuesday asking the regulator to essentially delay Wednesday’s vote until asset managers get clarity on how the fees, likely to be passed along to retail and other traders, will affect investment returns.

Sifma also flagged the new system’s mounting tab — estimated at $500 million at the end of last year — as another cause for concern and called for an independent party to review the database’s costs.

On Wednesday, Sifma and the American Securities Association fired back at the SEC’s approval.

In an emailed statement, ASA President and Chief Executive Chris Iacovella called the fees “a tax on American investors” and said the association views the system as an “unconstitutional collection” of investors’ personal and financial data. Sifma said the measure was an “unfair allocation of CAT costs” on brokers.

Hester Peirce, one of the SEC’s two Republican commissioners, said the agency had failed “to grapple with the need to establish a realistic constraint on CAT costs.”

Brokers are already doing much of the required trade reporting but haven’t been paying the fees needed to launch the database. Exchanges have been footing the bill for the audit-trail system so far.

Surge in private jet travel offers insights into economy, says JSSI CEO

Latest News

Foundation Source clients top $1.5B in grants as philanthropic giving surges
Foundation Source clients top $1.5B in grants as philanthropic giving surges

New wealth, evolving donor expectations, and responsible AI are reshaping charitable planning for advisors.

Schwab, LPL, and Fidelity veterans launch AI firm for wealth executives
Schwab, LPL, and Fidelity veterans launch AI firm for wealth executives

Bridge Operating Partners debuts with deep industry pedigree and a proprietary AI system designed to sharpen decision-making for wealth firm executives.

Advisor moves: Osaic and Raymond James add $507M in talent
Advisor moves: Osaic and Raymond James add $507M in talent

Two San Clemente teams leave LPL for Osaic while a Delray Beach trio departs Ameriprise for Raymond James’s independent advisor channel

Osaic discloses conflict tied to overlapping Envestnet ownership
Osaic discloses conflict tied to overlapping Envestnet ownership

Osaic’s Form ADV says majority owner Reverence Capital’s stake in Envestnet gives the firm and its advisors an incentive to recommend Envestnet programs. Reverence and Bain Capital backs both firms.

IRS hands down final auto enrollment rules for new 401(k), 403(b) plans
IRS hands down final auto enrollment rules for new 401(k), 403(b) plans

Treasury’s final SECURE 2.0 regulations give plan sponsors flexibility, though Vanguard calls for existing plans to face the mandate too.

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.