Elizabeth Warren's wealth-tax proposal could spur exodus to alternative assets

Elizabeth Warren's wealth-tax proposal could spur exodus to alternative assets
Billionaires 'would try to find assets that they can hide.'
NOV 08, 2019
By  Bloomberg
Sen. Elizabeth Warren's proposed wealth tax could be a gift to an industry she has accused of looting Americans — private equity. The Democratic presidential hopeful's plan to fund Medicare for All, denounced by prominent rich people like Bill Gates, hinges on a 6% annual levy on accumulated wealth in excess of $1 billion. One of the few ways for the extremely wealthy to preserve capital if such a tax were enacted would be putting their money into so-called alternative assets managed by firms such as Blackstone Group Inc., Carlyle Group and KKR & Co. [More:Elizabeth Warren health care plan sparks outcry over 401(k) tax hike] "A wealth tax is likely to result in some flow of funds away from public markets, where they can get easily valued, to investments where valuations are much harder," said Wojciech Kopczuk, a Columbia University economics professor. "It's possible that it will encourage higher risk, higher expected-return investments." Yolanda Plaza-Charres, director of investment strategy and solutions for SEI Private Wealth Management, was more specific. "We believe that such a tax would increase the use of alternative investments in the portfolios of the wealthy and ultra-wealthy," she said in an email response to questions. For Ms. Warren, that would amount to an unintended consequence — one that she's tried to address. In July, the Massachusetts lawmaker introduced the "Stop Wall Street Looting Act" to rein in private equity. The proposal would hold buyout firms liable for the debts of their portfolio companies, an idea that would be "industry-destroying," according to Argus Research Corp. analyst Steve Biggar. Gabriel Zucman, a University of California at Berkeley professor and an economic adviser for the campaigns of Ms. Warren and Senator Bernie Sanders, said it's unclear whether the wealth tax "in itself would affect the portfolio allocation of wealthy individuals." "If they could get higher returns by investing in private equity, they should already be doing this today," he said in an email. The Warren campaign didn't respond to requests for comment. [More:Why financial advisers hate Elizabeth Warren] The very wealthy often put liquid capital in low-risk investments such as U.S. Treasuries and municipal bonds to keep their fortunes from eroding. That could change, however, in a financial landscape that requires a 6% return just to break even. For a sense of how the wealthiest might react, consider how pension funds and endowments have adapted to low interest rates. They've increasingly turned away from stocks and bonds and concentrated more on private equity. The average pension fund held 27% of its assets in alternative investments, a category that includes hedge funds and private equity, at the end of 2017, according to a Fitch Ratings Inc. study. That's up from 9% in 2001. Ms. Warren has said that the 6% is just a fraction of what rich individuals can gain by investing in the S&P 500. And it's true that the average annual return for the index since 1928 has been 9.24%, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. But as any fund prospectus will tell you, past results aren't indicative of future returns. An analysis by Grantham Mayo Van Otterloo & Co. is downbeat on what the next seven years hold for investors. The firm's projections show only one traditional asset class — emerging-market value stocks — exceeding 5.3% in annual returns. [Recommended video: Why financial advisers hate Elizabeth Warren] That might sound bearish, but assumptions from BlackRock Inc., the world's biggest asset manager, aren't much rosier. In its scenario, U.S. stocks and bonds lag the 6% threshold over the next seven years while private equity funds exceed it. Other projections — such as Tobin's Q, Shiller's CAPE ratio and Warren Buffett's market capitalization to GDP — all point toward an age of turbulence for U.S. stocks. That doesn't mean private equity, which invests in a variety of assets — such as distressed debt, real estate and underperforming companies — would offer a safe harbor for smart money. "If private equity involves the potential of losing 85% of your investment in something like WeWork, when it goes from $47 billion to $7.4 billion, it makes the wealth tax look more like a cost of doing business if your business is capital preservation," said Daniel Alpert, managing partner of Westwood Capital in New York. "Risk can cost a lot more than the tax." Leon Cooperman, an investor the Bloomberg Billionaires Index says is worth $2.2 billion, has publicly battled Ms. Warren over the wealth tax, calling it "a stupid idea" and a "nightmare." In an interview, he said that while he's willing to work half the year for the government and half the year for himself, his fellow 600 or so American billionaires might have other ideas. "People," Mr. Cooperman said, "would try to find assets that they can hide." Our final Women Adviser Summit of 2019 will be held in New York City. Register now.

Latest News

A welcome mat into financial planning
A welcome mat into financial planning

The pandemic hit and internships were in chaos but Hannah Moore saw an opportunity.

RIAs need to visit universities to attract students
RIAs need to visit universities to attract students

RIAs need to find universities that offer financial planning programs and sponsor or host events, advisor suggests.

Orion deepens Capital Group alliance with ETF portfolio tie-up
Orion deepens Capital Group alliance with ETF portfolio tie-up

The leading wealth tech provider is helping more advisors access active ETF models through its exclusive partnership.

JPMorgan client who lost $50M amid dementia battle denied trial
JPMorgan client who lost $50M amid dementia battle denied trial

Case of once-wealthy family highlights risks, raises questions on firms' duties to sophisticated investors suffering cognitive decline.

Stifel loses huge $14.2 million arbitration claim linked to star Miami broker
Stifel loses huge $14.2 million arbitration claim linked to star Miami broker

“The evidence in this case was overwhelming,” says an attorney.

SPONSORED Leading through innovation – with Tom Ruggie of Destiny Wealth Partners

Uncover the key initiatives behind Destiny Wealth Partners’ success and how it became one of the fastest growing fee-only RIAs.

SPONSORED Client engagement strategies, growth and retention in the down markets

Key insights from Gabriel Garcia on adapting to demographic shifts and enhancing client experience in a changing market