IRS turns up the heat on stock collar transactions

IRVINE, Calif. — The Internal Revenue Service is threatening to bring more cases against wealthy investors who have used a popular technique to hedge concentrated stock holdings.
FEB 26, 2007
By  Bloomberg
IRVINE, Calif. — The Internal Revenue Service is threatening to bring more cases against wealthy investors who have used a popular technique to hedge concentrated stock holdings. The agency has reiterated a year-old warning that a type of stock collar known as a “variable prepaid forward contract” resulted in sale of the stock for tax purposes. In a memo last month, the IRS encouraged its staff members to “develop these cases” and said: “We stand ready to assist you in the legal analysis.” Under a prepaid forward arrangement, clients get cash upfront and contract with brokerage firms to deliver a variable number of shares or cash several years later, at which time taxes are due. Last year, the IRS issued a technical-advice memorandum that challenged arrangements where the brokerage firm also borrows the client’s shares and shorts them as part of a hedge (InvestmentNews, May 8). That kind of structure created a sale, the IRS said. Wall Street has sold billions of dollars of these deals. If stock loans were involved, clients could owe taxes and possibly penalties. The latest memo from the IRS “certainly removes any doubt from this issue,” said Robert Gordon, chief executive at Twenty-First Securities Corp. in New York, a boutique that uses hedging techniques for wealthy investors. “It’s a nail in [the] coffin” for contracts that involved stock lending, he said. Mr. Gordon said that since last year, when the IRS issued its first warning memo, the industry largely has stopped using share-lending agreements with clients. The IRS didn’t respond to requests for comment. Tough languageCritics seek clarity Critics have blasted the IRS’ view that a contract to sell shares and a share-lending agreement is one transaction, which causes a constructive sale. In a detailed letter to the IRS in November, New York-based law firm Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP, which represents industry interests, said that the IRS’ analysis is “vague and imprecisely articulated.” Kenneth Gideon, a Skadden Arps partner in Washington, declined to comment. Industry lawyers say that the IRS’ analysis contradicts a tax revenue ruling from 2003. In its memo last month, the IRS shot back, Mr. Leeds said. The agency called arguments from industry lawyers “specious” and “misdirected,” and said that viewing a sale-and-lending agreement separately “would be ignoring the economic realities of the transaction.” Mr. Leeds said that the IRS is upset that the industry didn’t make clear the extent to which share lending was occurring when the agency took comments on its 2003 ruling. Meanwhile, the IRS is looking into how the Street has structured prepaid forward contracts. Mr. Leeds said that he represents some financial institutions that “have received very broad requests [from the IRS] for information on variable prepaid forward contracts.” The agency summoned the information in connection with audits of the institutions’ clients, he said. The largest requests for information started in August and have continued, Mr. Leeds said.

Latest News

Investor anxiety hits six-year high amid market turmoil, Allianz finds
Investor anxiety hits six-year high amid market turmoil, Allianz finds

New survey reveals heightened investor concern over market volatility, retirement readiness, and the impact of tariffs on living costs.

Stifel star broker, Chuck Roberts, leaves firm under cloud of investor complaints
Stifel star broker, Chuck Roberts, leaves firm under cloud of investor complaints

Stifel – so far - is on the hook for more than $166 million in damages, legal fees and settlements in investor complaints involving Roberts, a 35-year industry veteran.

RIA moves: The Mather Group, Brand Asset Management announce deals
RIA moves: The Mather Group, Brand Asset Management announce deals

Consolidation continues in US wealth management industry.

US broker-dealer fintech aims for global footprint as it acquires international firm
US broker-dealer fintech aims for global footprint as it acquires international firm

Tech company democratizes access to US trading infrastructure.

Advisor moves: RBC swipes $1.7B UBS team, Baird duo departs for LPL's Linsco channel
Advisor moves: RBC swipes $1.7B UBS team, Baird duo departs for LPL's Linsco channel

RBC Wealth Management's latest move in New York adds an elite eight-member team to its recently opened Westchester office.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.