Merrill Lynch: Culture change or just the latest innovation?

JUN 09, 2010
For all of my 26 years as a headhunter, Merrill Lynch has been the most stable wealth management firm in the industry, as well as the most significant innovator. On the stability front, let’s recognize that their name has not changed and recognize what that represents. Bank of America bought Merrill Lynch, albeit in a shotgun wedding with the government holding the shotgun, but kept the Merrill name. Though Merrill made some minor acquisitions over the years (for example, Advest/Lebenthal), they did nothing that would come close to changing their brand. Senior leadership was always promoted from within, often with careers that began as an Advisor. Compare that to Morgan Stanley Smith Barney. If we include some of the mega-mergers behind that corporate name, it actually would look like: “Morgan Stanley Dean Witter Smith Barney Shearson Hutton (Lehman for a little while) Legg Mason”. If we go back further, many more would be added in. Merrill’s strength has been partly this consistency of culture and also innovation: they brought financial planning into the wirehouses, invented the CMA, and scared many Advisors from leaving (pre Broker Protocol) by the aggressive use of the Temporary Restraining Order. More recently, Merrill Advisors tell me that they can now see the assets that their clients have at Bank of America with a separate tab on their desktop. This accomplished in one year what Citi/Smith Barney could not do in over ten. As an industry historian, as well as an unabashed cynic, I’m fascinated with this type of merger and how it affects the cultures of both institutions over time. Sallie Krawcheck, an outsider who failed to effectively bridge the Citi-Smith Barney divide, and who was never an Advisor herself, is running Merrill Lynch within B of A. Over the last year, Merrill has capitalized on the turmoil within post-joint venture Morgan Stanley Smith Barney by hiring a talented group of their Branch Managers and one former Regional Director: Jimmy Tighe, Jason Weaver, Ken Ross, Peter Ardolino, and Michael Simonds. I’ve never seen Merrill so aggressive in bringing in outside management talent in such a short period of time. While Merrill Advisors welcome the continued innovation, they also complain about increased bureaucracy within B of A, and an HR-centric culture that clashes with the entrepreneurialism of the typical Merrill practice. In the past, it has been rare for a large branch to be taken over by anyone other than a long time Merrill veteran who started as an Advisor within Merrill Lynch years before. Those recent recruits are not cheap and will not be sitting on the sidelines. They soon will be running complexes, branches, and down the road, regions. So, is this the first wave of cracks in that famous closed culture? Or is this poaching of talent just the latest “innovation” to keep the organization fresh?

Latest News

AI 'leadership swirl' distracts wealth execs from growth, says Bridge CEO
AI 'leadership swirl' distracts wealth execs from growth, says Bridge CEO

Eddie Brown says RIA executives need AI built for strategy and execution, not just advisor productivity

RIA moves: Summit, UWP deals keep founders in charge; SagePoint adds RISE
RIA moves: Summit, UWP deals keep founders in charge; SagePoint adds RISE

Independent advisors in Colorado, Texas and Arkansas join larger wealth management platforms through acquisitions and partnerships

SEC censures Pacific West sales agent but declines industry bar
SEC censures Pacific West sales agent but declines industry bar

The enforcement division wanted a full bar - the Commission went lighter

CW Advisors buys $920M Woburn RIA, its seventh deal under Osaic
CW Advisors buys $920M Woburn RIA, its seventh deal under Osaic

Welch brothers’ 93 Financial Group gives the Osaic-owned RIA a fifth greater Boston office, days after a $1.6B triple acquisition

Shareholder sues Anson Funds over alleged $165.9M in short-swing profits
Shareholder sues Anson Funds over alleged $165.9M in short-swing profits

The hedge fund group allegedly held a financing 'vice grip' over the company

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.