Wells Fargo analyst questions Morgan Stanley's $20M bonuses

Wells Fargo analyst questions Morgan Stanley's $20M bonuses
Mike Mayo says the payouts to three senior leaders suggest governance risk.
OCT 31, 2023

Morgan Stanley’s decision to award $20 million special bonuses to its runners-up for chief executive officer points to a governance risk, raising questions about their commitment to the company, according to Wells Fargo & Co. analyst Mike Mayo.

The Wall Street bank named Ted Pick its next CEO last week, saying his top competitors for the post, Andy Saperstein and Dan Simkowitz, would stay on, too. The plan includes share-based awards initially valued at $20 million apiece for all three executives, roughly equal to a year of their historic pay.

Mayo said that means the succession plan is “more reliant on comp than realized,” showing the bank is “paying top execs to stay, which to us at least raises a question about whether they are staying more due to comp than culture.”

The firm’s longtime CEO, James Gorman, had publicly vowed to defy a norm on Wall Street, in which big firms elevate a new boss only to set off a cascade of personnel changes as the incoming leader’s rivals depart. Bucking that trend, Morgan Stanley said last week that Saperstein and Simkowitz will remain at the company as co-presidents.  

Each award consists of 60% performance-stock units, with a performance period of 2024 to 2026, that convert to shares in 2027. The remaining 40% is comprised of restricted-stock units that vest and become shares in January 2027. The performance-stock units pay out in full only if the company reaches certain financial targets.

Latest News

Trump teleprompter operator placed on unpaid leave amid probe into alleged Kalshi bets
Trump teleprompter operator placed on unpaid leave amid probe into alleged Kalshi bets

“The White House has extremely strict ethical guidelines with respect to issues like this,” said Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt.

GPB, the priest and a get out of jail card
GPB, the priest and a get out of jail card

Just how much does it cost for a financial advice exec to stay out of prison?

St. Louis pension fund sues FS/KKR advisor over alleged excessive fees
St. Louis pension fund sues FS/KKR advisor over alleged excessive fees

The advisor both prices FSK's private loans and gets paid on those prices, the suit claims

SEC moves to make electronic delivery the default for investor disclosures
SEC moves to make electronic delivery the default for investor disclosures

The proposal would end decades of paper-first delivery rules, but keeps a paper opt-out and draws early praise from fund and annuity industry groups.

Trump accounts could encompass every US family, 70 million children, says IRS chief
Trump accounts could encompass every US family, 70 million children, says IRS chief

The Trump accounts are “generationally changing” and bring financial literacy to youth, said IRS chief Frank Bisignano.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income