When the sunset deal dims the value

This article is produced in partnership with Sanctuary Wealth Group, LLC.

A wirehouse advisor producing $3 million a year can reach the final stretch of a career with a sizable retirement package waiting. Vince Fertitta thinks the number can obscure what is being surrendered.

Fertitta, president of Sanctuary Wealth, spends much of his time walking advisors through what that package actually represents next to the alternative: building an independent practice and selling it as an asset. Advisors weighing a firm’s sunset program should make a more exacting comparison.

“It’s the easy pass,” he says, “and for many advisors, it is simply the only path they have ever seriously considered because it is the only one they know.” By the time they are weighing an exit, the energy required to build something of their own has often gone.

The dollar figure makes that trade-off concrete. It’s not just the exit valuation that drives the economics, he says. It’s also the cash flow before the exit.

Fertitta offers a rule of thumb, his own estimate rather than an audited industry figure: For every $100,000 a financial advisor produces each month as an employee, he or she gives up roughly $20,000 by remaining an employee.

A $3 million producer, by that math, forfeits close to $600,000 annually for every year the move to independence is delayed. He adds that independence should never be rushed into either. The point is that time spent undecided carries a price, and few advisors ever calculate it.

The cost of waiting

The confusion, Fertitta argues, starts with a basic misunderstanding: A sunset payout and a business sale are not variations on the same theme. They are structurally different transactions with different outcomes attached.

A sunset program is compensation, paid out over time, usually with conditions attached, while the firm keeps the clients and the future revenue stream. An advisor who owns their practice, by contrast, is selling an asset. They can negotiate valuation, choose their buyer and structure the deal with more favorable tax treatment.

That treatment alone widens the gap considerably: Sunset payments are taxed as ordinary income, while proceeds from an independent sale generally receive capital gains treatment.

There’s also a team on the other side of that transaction whose members may not understand what they’re buying or may feel pressured to agree to terms they know are less than ideal.

“The team is only paying for the right to receive income from the retiring advisor’s book at a payout subject to change at the employer’s discretion,” Fertitta says.

That income is also contingent on the team staying in good standing with the firm. The inheriting team accepts the terms because they don’t want to be difficult or unappreciative toward the retiring advisor, but they know that while it may seem like a windfall, it’s not a great deal.

What actually commands a premium

While independence on its own unlocks the asset’s value, establishing an exit valuation far greater than a wirehouse sunset payout, just how valuable the business is depends on metrics the owner can control. Fertitta says buyers look closely at whether the revenue can survive the founder.

Strong production helps, but so do predictable fee-based revenues, organic growth, margins, a repeatable investment process and a team that can carry relationships forward. A practice in which every important decision still runs through one advisor is harder to transfer, however impressive the top line.

A sunset program, by contrast, hands the formula, the timing and the conditions to the firm.

“Compensation does not equal ownership,” Fertitta notes. Advisors build the team and the client relationships and generate the revenue, but when they retire, the firm keeps the clients and the future income, and the advisor is left with a contractual payout well below market value.

Ownership also leaves more room to decide how the exit happens. Fertitta points to the ability to sell all or part of a business, remain involved after the transaction, retain equity or choose a buyer whose plans for the firm align with the seller’s own. Tax and estate planning can be built around the transaction rather than worked around a preset formula.

Buyers look for predictable fee-based income, organic growth, a durable and scalable investment process, solid margins and client relationships that don’t rest on one person answering every call.

“A high-revenue practice may produce substantial income today,” Fertitta says. “A transferable business gives a buyer confidence that the income will continue.”

Even then, he warns against chasing a headline multiple in isolation.

“If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is,” he says. A high multiple often assumes a sustained growth rate for years after closing, along with other conditions that can reshape the real value of the deal.

Treat your own exit like a client’s

The final few years matter, Fertitta emphasizes, because the range of choices narrows quickly. An advisor who waits until a sunset agreement is already on the desk may still be able to leave, but the appetite for another transition is often gone and much of the economic benefit of ownership has already been forgone.

Fertitta wants advisors to put a value on the practice, model the after-tax proceeds under each route and understand what each option leaves behind for the team.

“They should approach their own exit with the same discipline they would recommend to a business-owner client,” he says. That includes looking past the headline number, testing the conditions underneath it and understanding what happens to the asset once they are gone.

The sunset program isn’t going anywhere. It will still be on the table once an advisor has priced the alternative, tested the conditions and decided what their own career is actually worth.

Learn More.