The Charles Schwab Corp. is the long-reigning largest service provider and custodian to registered investment advisors, with reportedly between $5 trillion and $6 trillion in assets from 17,000 RIA fi rms and financial advisors.
Adding to its heft and reputation as industry leader, Schwab just a few years ago pulled off a corporate coup: the acquisition of a former main competitor, TD Ameritrade Holding Corp., for $26 billion in stock.
The deal only added to Schwab’s stature and reach.
But dominance can be fleeting on Wall Street.
And Schwab and the rest of the RIA custody market were thrown into a shock in August when the Vanguard Group, the global leader in fund management, said it was buying fintech platform and Schwab competitor Altruist for reportedly close to $4 billion.
Altruist last year launched Hazel, an AI platform designed for financial advisors. Over the winter, news of Altruist’s AI tax-planning tool sent the share prices of competitors, including Schwab, sharply lower.
Altruist is not much of a threat to Schwab, but Vanguard is,” said Brad Bueermann, CEO and founder of FP Transitions, a leading consultancy for RIAs, on a recent episode of the InvestmentNews Podcast. “Given the size and scale, that’s interesting. We’re watching how this affects advisors.”
“Vanguard was likely thinking not just about Altruist but thinking Hazel, the AI that Altruist pioneered,” Bueermann said. “That was ahead of the curve, by months, in terms of what we’ve seen when it comes to the explosion of AI connectors in the industry.”
“Vanguard is effectively coming over to the side of independent advisors,” he added. “I think that’s a huge move.”
A spokesperson for Vanguard did not comment for this story.
As InvestmentNews noted in August, the Vanguard purchase of Altruist marks one of the most significant consolidations in advisor technology this year, bringing together the country’s largest mutual fund manager with a firm that has spent the past several years working to modernize the RIA custody business.
Founded in 2018, Altruist is being pitched to RIAs and their potential clients as the go-to technology savvy custodian right now.
“Many investors in Vanguard funds choose to work with financial advisors, and far more people could benefit from access to financial advice than the industry can serve today,” said Salim Ramji, Vanguard CEO, in a statement announcing the deal. “Technology can help close that gap by enabling advisors to serve more people and serve them better, while preserving the human judgement and relationships at the center of good financial advice.”
With its top-shelf technology, will Altruist, now backed by Vanguard, threaten Schwab’s leadership in the RIA marketplace? Financial advisors and industry executives have reflected on this since the deal’s announcement.
After all, Altruist earlier this year launched a corporate RIA structure designed to ease the path for so-called breakaway advisors, or brokers leaving wirehouses, to work as more highly paid independent RIAs. And some advisors who use Schwab to custody client assets have privately grumbled at times about service to advisors left waiting on the phone to call centers with questions about clients’ accounts.
One Wall Street analyst in September batted aside any concerns Vanguard’s Altruist purchase might hold for Schwab.
“The Altruist/Vanguard deal not a meaningful threat,” wrote Steven Chubak, managing director of Wolfe Research and a leading brokerage analyst, in a research note.
He had earlier met with senior Schwab management to inform his assessment and said he was maintaining his “bullish” outlook on the company.
A spokesperson for Schwab said Chubak’s comments were consistent with the discussion in his meeting with the company’s senior management but declined to comment further.
“Altruist remains a small player with limited capabilities, and [Schwab] has seen an acceleration in RIA flows over [the last year],” Chubak noted. “We do not believe this deal meaningfully alters the competitive landscape.”
Pump the brakes on that way of thinking, other industry executives responded.
Can the RIA custody market afford to ignore Altruist’s technology or the role of Vanguard, which wants to expand into the financial advice marketplace?
“When it comes to RIAs, it’s an arms race on the technology front,” said Peter Nesvold, managing partner of his eponymous firm Nesvold Capital. “The RIA custodian business in five years won’t look like what it is today.”
“The one-stop shopping for technology solutions for advisors is where Altruist adds value,” Nesvold added.
Altruist clearly has its supporters and will likely soon have a larger market share in the RIA custody industry.
AdvizorPro.com called Altruist a “standout” among Schwab’s competitors as a technology-focused custodian.
AdvizorPro is an online data and research hub for RIAs and advisors.
Altruist has experienced remarkable growth over the past few years, emerging as a top choice for many new RIAs seeking a custodian partner,” wrote AdvizorPro.com in its annual analysis of custodians, months before Vanguard said it was buying Altruist. “Its popularity surge is a testament to the fact that new RIAs value innovative solutions and exceptional service, making Altruist an attractive option for forward-thinking RIAs.”
Welch brothers’ 93 Financial Group gives the Osaic-owned RIA a fifth greater Boston office, days after a $1.6B triple acquisition
New wealth, evolving donor expectations, and responsible AI are reshaping charitable planning for advisors.
Bridge Operating Partners debuts with deep industry pedigree and a proprietary AI system designed to sharpen decision-making for wealth firm executives.
Two San Clemente teams leave LPL for Osaic while a Delray Beach trio departs Ameriprise for Raymond James’s independent advisor channel
Osaic’s Form ADV says majority owner Reverence Capital’s stake in Envestnet gives the firm and its advisors an incentive to recommend Envestnet programs. Reverence and Bain Capital backs both firms.
Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives
Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.