Fat fees, conflicts made sales of GPB private placements 'illegal': investor complaint

Fat fees, conflicts made sales of GPB private placements 'illegal': investor complaint
GPB’s strategy was destined to fail, according to the lawsuit
MAY 12, 2020

Astronomical fees and undisclosed conflicts of interest undermined investors in GPB Capital private placements from the start, according to an amended prospective class action lawsuit filed last week in federal court in Austin, Texas.

Launched in 2013, GPB Capital marketed itself to investors seeking steady returns by investing in auto dealerships and trash hauling businesses. GPB raised $1.8 billion from investors, who bought the private placements through at least 60 broker-dealers that charged steep commissions on the sales.

GPB and its investors have endured a cascade of difficulties. The company has been under investigation by the SEC and FBI. In October, the Department of Justice charged GPB Capital’s chief compliance officer, who was also a former SEC examiner, with obstruction of justice relating to the SEC investigation of GPB.

The amended class action complaint, Kinnie Ma IRA v. Ascendant Capital takes aim at the unrevealed conflicts of interest of two owners of the GPB businesses, David Gentile and Jeffrey Schneider.

In addition to being an owner of GPB, Schneider was one of the owners of Ascendant Capital, the broker-dealer that contacted other brokers to sell the private placements. This conflict should have been revealed to investors, according to the complaint.

“Ascendant Capital, GPB’s primary distribution agent, and GPB itself, were both controlled by their principals, David Gentile and Jeffry Schneider,” according to the complaint. “However, neither GPB, nor Ascendant, nor their principals made disclosure of this co-ownership and common control to investors in the offering materials for the Securities.”

“The failure to disclose this gross conflict of interest — that the issuers of GPB securities and the purportedly independent agent selling these securities were commonly controlled — rendered the offerings of these securities illegal,” the complaint alleges.

The astronomical fees of 16% to 20% of investors’ money also harmed clients, who had been pitched yields of 8% and an internal rate of return for each GPB investment of 15%, according to the complaint. That means for each $1 million of gross investment, only approximately $800,000 of investor cash was actually available for investment, according to the complaint.

“GPB’s ‘investment strategy’ was destined to fail because it included exorbitant, unprecedented fees, which were not accurately described in its” sales documents, according to the complaint.

A spokesperson for GPB, Nancy Sterling, said in an email: “We have reviewed the suit and believe it has no merit. We will vigorously argue against it in court."

Last summer, the company said that GPB Holdings II and GPB Automotive Portfolio had seen declines in value of 25.4% and 39%, respectively. The two funds raised $1.27 billion from investors and make up the lion’s share of GPB Capital’s portfolio.

Latest News

Freehold Wealth Management brings $576M to Osaic in multigenerational move
Freehold Wealth Management brings $576M to Osaic in multigenerational move

South Carolina estate planning firm joins Osaic’s IBD network, citing succession planning tools and multigenerational growth resources.

Investors still want advisors, even as AI expands investment choices
Investors still want advisors, even as AI expands investment choices

A new SIFMA and KPMG study of more than 2,100 US investors finds satisfaction high, AI-only trust falling, and demand for human guidance growing across every generation.

AI poses moderate disruption risk to wealth managers and retail banks, Fitch says
AI poses moderate disruption risk to wealth managers and retail banks, Fitch says

Retail banks and private wealth firms scored 40 in Fitch's AI stress test, signaling possible one-notch downgrade risk under an adverse scenario.

Advisor moves: RBC lands $1B UBS team in Pittsburgh
Advisor moves: RBC lands $1B UBS team in Pittsburgh

Elsewhere, Wells Fargo Advisors adds a $400 million Morgan Stanley veteran in Naples as an ex-Cetera advisor goes independent with LPL

GWG’s Heppner hires Puff Daddy’s attorneys as criminal sentencing looms
GWG’s Heppner hires Puff Daddy’s attorneys as criminal sentencing looms

According to a federal charges Bradley Heppner, 60, received more than $150 million in payments through funneling money from GWG Holdings to a shell company.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.

SPONSORED In the Age of AI, Trust Becomes the Advisor's Greatest Asset

As AI makes financial information more accessible than ever, Lana Hock explains why human judgment, trust, and empathy remain the qualities clients value most in a financial advisor