With anti-DOL fiduciary rule lawsuits, industry organizations' actions speak louder than words

With anti-DOL fiduciary rule lawsuits, industry organizations' actions speak louder than words
How can those suing to quash the DOL rule, like SIFMA CEO Ken Bentsen Jr., claim to also support its premise?
JUN 27, 2016
Just before explaining why they filed a lawsuit to kill the DOL fiduciary rule, every industry trade group is careful to assert that they, in fact, support its premise. Yes, they want to do away with the Labor Department measure that would require financial advisers to act in the best interests of their clients in retirement accounts, but it would be hard for them to win public favor arguing they just don't want to have to put clients first. They contend, instead, that they've been in favor of a fiduciary standard since just before Adam met Eve — or at least prior to 2010, when the DOL first began its work.

SOFTENING THE BLOW

In a June 2 media conference call introducing the industry lawsuit, Ken Bentsen Jr., president and CEO of the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, tried to soften the blow of opposing a measure designed to ensure people get good investment advice on their nest eggs. “The industry, including SIFMA, have long been on record, well-documented, in support of a uniform fiduciary standard of care for financial advisers when providing personalized investment advice,” Mr. Bentsen said. “The industry believes the client's best interest should be put first.” Dale Brown, president and CEO of the Financial Services Institute, a co-plaintiff, said his organization also is squarely behind a fiduciary standard. “Being pro-fiduciary is not something new to us or our members,” he said on the same media call. And then came the “but.” “But the Department of Labor's complex and unworkable rule will only harm the smaller investor it claims to protect,” Mr. Brown said. (More: Dale Brown on why FSI is suing the DOL) There it is, the favorite adjective of industry opponents: unworkable. They've put that label on the DOL rule since its first iteration in 2010. But since then the rule has undergone a litany of changes, many of which specifically added more protections for the brokerage model in response to an avalanche of industry criticism.

BROKER-FRIENDLY CHANGES

For instance, the final rule explicitly states that proprietary products can be sold to clients. The agency also removed a list of preferred assets for retirement accounts, opening them up to the types of high commission products independent broker-dealers (i.e., FSI members) like to sell. Of course, advisers would have to justify why they think nontraded real estate investment trusts, for instance, belong in a retirement account. The DOL's changes to the final rule brought it closer to the standard envisioned by the Dodd-Frank financial reform law, which said fiduciary duty could not ban the sale of proprietary products or impose a continuing duty of care on brokers after a sale is made. Still, the industry was not satisfied. “Show me the fiduciary standard they like,” said Jon Lukomnik, managing partner at Sinclair Capital and co-author of “What They Do with Your Money” (Yale University Press, 2016).“Their actions speak louder than their words.” A year ago, SIFMA did offer a way to modify the less-stringent suitability standard to which brokers now adhere and turn it into a best-interests standard. Under the plan, brokers would have to disclose and manage investment-related fees and avoid or disclose and manage conflicts of interest. The standard would be enforced by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc., the industry-funded broker regulator.

PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION

The problem is that SIFMA is proposing to wordsmith a standard that even Finra chairman and chief executive Richard G. Ketchum said is not enough to protect investors. “They're not for any best-interests standard,” said Knut Rostad, president of the Institute for the Fiduciary Standard. “They have rebranded their sales suitability standard.” Finra enforcement doesn't strike the same fear into the hearts of financial firms as the private right of action contained in the DOL rule, which allows investors to file class-action lawsuits.

WAITING FOR THE SEC

What the industry really wants is to have the Securities and Exchange Commission act on the authority given to it to by Dodd-Frank to promulgate a uniform fiduciary standard. But the five-person SEC has been hamstrung by a political split over a proposal, with two Republican commissioners in opposition and one of the Democrats non-committal. The industry knows this. Waiting for the SEC to act leaves investment advice pretty much where these groups would like it to stay: status quo. No matter how often industry leaders begin their attacks on the DOL rule by stating how much they support a best-interests standard, the bottom line is they are trying to kill the first regulation that would deliver it to investors.

Latest News

Advisor moves: RBC swipes $1.7B UBS team, Baird duo departs for LPL's Linsco channel
Advisor moves: RBC swipes $1.7B UBS team, Baird duo departs for LPL's Linsco channel

RBC Wealth Management's latest move in New York adds an elite eight-member team to its recently opened Westchester office.

Stifel star broker, Chuck Roberts, leaves firm under cloud of investor complaints
Stifel star broker, Chuck Roberts, leaves firm under cloud of investor complaints

Stifel – so far - is on the hook for more than $166 million in damages, legal fees and settlements in investor complaints involving Roberts, a 35-year industry veteran.

iCapital secures $820M in latest funding, hits $7.5B
iCapital secures $820M in latest funding, hits $7.5B

The giant alt investments platform's latest financing led by T. Rowe Price and SurgoCap Partners, along with State Street, UBS, and BNY, will fuel additional growth on multiple fronts.

Merrill Lynch on the hook for $3.7M after clients claimed sale of unsuitable private equity
Merrill Lynch on the hook for $3.7M after clients claimed sale of unsuitable private equity

Some investors recently have seen million dollar plus decisions by FINRA arbitration panels involving complex products decisions go their way.

What does it take to feel 'financially comfortable' or 'wealthy' in 2025?
What does it take to feel 'financially comfortable' or 'wealthy' in 2025?

New report shines a light on how Americans view wealth today.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.