Selling your advisory firm internally could mean taking a valuation hit

Echelon executive argues that internal sales can mean taking a valuation hit.
JUN 07, 2018

Advisory firm owners who are considering selling their firm internally in a succession-plan transaction rather than to outside buyers might be taking a valuation hit, according to Daniel Seivert, chief executive of investment bank Echelon Partners.​ "Internal deals are more difficult than people think, and because there's no competitive process, valuation discounts are the norm," he said Thursday morning during a panel discussion at Pershing Advisor Solutions' annual Insite conference in Orlando, Fla. Mr. Seivert, who participated in a point-counterpoint debate on advisory firm merger and acquisition strategies along with Pershing Advisor Solutions CEO Mark Tibergien, said 60% of deals now involve internal buyers. That percentage is up from 40% 10 years ago, Mr. Seivert said. While Mr. Tibergien pointed out that an internal sale can be "the first step in creating continuity in an enterprise, and optimizes value," Mr. Seivert said external deals "lead to valuation premiums." "There is no synergy value in an internal sale because no new element is being brought in to the business," Mr. Seivert said. "Also the process of an internal deal can tear at the fabric of your practice." Another hurdle for internal deals, Mr. Seivert said, is that "buyers often have no experience with the financing and legal elements, and that part can be difficult, especially for younger buyers." The panel discussion, moderated by Megan Carpenter, chief executive and co-founder of financial services communications firm FiComm Partners, was less about taking sides then it was about provoking thought among the audience of about 100 financial advisers. For example, on the topic of outsourcing investment management, Mr. Tibergien challenged the audience on why most of them charge fees based on assets, yet consider themselves holistic financial planners. "This is the only profession I know of where the fee is based on the value the client brings to the business," he said. "If something is the core of your value proposition, you should own it. But if it's a satellite value, you should rent it." Mr. Seivert elaborated on the value of outsourcing investment management if the goal is to be the target of an acquiring firm. "It makes you more M&A-ready if you don't have an investment team because buyers often don't want it or don't want to pay for it," he said. "Also, if you're the asset manager and something goes wrong with the portfolio, you're responsible and that can get your fired." Mr. Seivert further drove the point home by pointing out that "proprietary investment management is time-consuming and it can take your focus off the business." "That's why firms with proprietary investment management are seen as higher risk and are valued at a discount," he added. (More: Focus Financial IPO could be a sell signal for RIAs)

Latest News

Senate Majority Leader pushes full repeal of estate tax
Senate Majority Leader pushes full repeal of estate tax

The Republican leader's call to end the death tax, part of a long and growing wish list of cuts and reductions, would offer relief to a small but important sliver of America's wealthiest taxpayers.

Wall Street bonuses surged 32% to $47.5B last year, NY comptroller says
Wall Street bonuses surged 32% to $47.5B last year, NY comptroller says

The 2024 bump in bonuses made for the largest total pool in records going back to 1987, but economic uncertainty and federal changes weigh on this year's outlook.

Advisors seek transparency on DIY investing as Robinhood faces investigation
Advisors seek transparency on DIY investing as Robinhood faces investigation

'I feel like they have created an addictive gaming culture, which is not healthy for investing.'

Dynasty forges RIA custody partnership with Goldman Sachs
Dynasty forges RIA custody partnership with Goldman Sachs

The collaboration gives Dynasty's $105 billion network of over 500 advisors access to new custodial services, asset management, and lending expertise.

Investors turn cold on hottest emerging-market ETF as China back in favor
Investors turn cold on hottest emerging-market ETF as China back in favor

Record redemptions from the ex-China strategy came as money managers consider Beijing's latest stimulus push and Chinese AI optimism.

SPONSORED Focus on clients, not compliance – why Gary Corderman found his fit with Farther

This wealth management platform finally delivers on the technology promises other firms couldn't - giving advisors a better way to scale and serve

SPONSORED Beyond the all-in-one: Why specialization is key in wealth tech

In an industry of broad solutions, firms like intelliflo prove 'you just need tools that play well together'