What percentage of Americans think the income tax they pay is fair?

What percentage of Americans think the income tax they pay is fair?
Spoiler alert: It’s the lowest share in 25 years, new report reveals
APR 08, 2025

With House Republicans continuing to debate a green light to extending the 2017 tax cuts, Americans are anticipating the impact that an extension – or not – would have on their finances.

But whatever lawmakers decide and how taxpayers view that decision, a recent survey reveals a declining share of people nationwide think that the federal income taxes they pay are fair.

The Gallup poll found that 50% of respondents do not think the tax they pay is fair, while 46% say it is. Those who think it is fair are in the smallest share since 1999 when 45% said this.

The peak ‘fair’ score was during World War II when up to 90% of Americans said this of the income taxes they had to pay, but in recent times (since Gallup reintroduced the question in 1997) the peak was in 2003 (64%) but this then trended lower (to 50% in 2016) until 2017 (61%), when the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act was introduced. It started trending lower again in 2019.

Whether the federal income taxes paid are fair or not, the survey also asked about the amount of tax being paid. In this regard, 59% of respondents say they pay too much, 39% say it’s about right, and 2% say they don’t pay enough.

Poll participants are also unhappy with the amount of tax that lower income people pay. While last year 50% felt those on lower incomes pay too much federal income tax, this increased to 58% this year with just 30% saying this cohort pays about the right amount while 10% think they should pay more.

More than half (54%) of respondents said that middle income earners pay too much, 40% think it’s about right, and 5% think it's too low.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, opinion flips when it comes to upper income earners with just 12% saying they pay too much tax, 28% saying it’s about right, and 58% think it’s not enough (although in the early 1990s this was 77%).

Corporations are also considered to pay too little tax (70% said so) with just 21% saying they pay their fair share, and 7% saying they pay too much.

 

 

Latest News

Navigating life’s big transitions for women clients
Navigating life’s big transitions for women clients

Divorce, widowhood, and retirement are events when financial advisors may provide stability and guidance.

Rethink cybersecurity disclosure rule, SIFMA urges SEC
Rethink cybersecurity disclosure rule, SIFMA urges SEC

The industry group and other financial associations called out risks from premature disclosures, overreporting, and bad actors weaponizing the rule's requirements.

Blackstone, Wellington Management, and Vanguard Group to run new interval fund; face big questions
Blackstone, Wellington Management, and Vanguard Group to run new interval fund; face big questions

In regards to the new fund, called WVB All Markets Fund, Morningstar analysts wrote that, “despite the brand-name pedigree of the asset managers involved, most of these strategies are untested.”

Gen AI gathers momentum as wealth firms scale digital plans
Gen AI gathers momentum as wealth firms scale digital plans

New Broadridge survey reveals surge in AI investments, with a third of respondents expecting a payoff within six months.

Vanguard effect loses potency as new ETFs post record high in fees
Vanguard effect loses potency as new ETFs post record high in fees

The latest launches in 2025, which include leveraged strategies, cryptocurrency, and active funds, mark a sharp turn from the passive revolution envisioned by Jack Bogle.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave

SPONSORED The evolution of private credit

From direct lending to asset-based finance to commercial real estate debt.