Annuities provider Knighthead Life has started investing in private credit after sitting out of the corporate lending boom entirely in 2025, CEO Edward Massaro tells InvestmentNews.
“We have about a 7 percent allocation across our portfolio to private credit,” says Massaro. “We didn’t have any exposure in 2025 to corporate private credit.”
The US private credit default rate reached a record high of 6.3% for the trailing 12 months ended August 2026, according to Fitch Ratings. Massaro says that most of Knighthead’s private credit exposure comes through large outside managers, but he distinguishes those managers from private credit fi rms that have recently faced elevated redemption requests and other pressures.
“Private credit is no different than syndicated loans in the 80s or the high yield market in the 90s. There’s less liquidity, but it’s an appropriate product for insurance carriers [when] done the right way,” says Massaro. “At the end of the day, we do have long-lived liabilities.”
Knighthead had no exposure to corporate private credit in 2025 because credit spreads had tightened to levels that Massaro says did not adequately compensate the company for illiquidity. Spreads have since widened to the “mid fours, sometimes 500” basis points over SOFR, he says, referring to the Secured Overnight Financing Rate benchmark interest rate.
“You don’t have to make an outsized return. What you have to do is get your money back. And I think we’ve proven that we can do that,” Massaro says of investing in private credit.
Annuity sales tracked by LIMRA reached $121.2 billion in the second quarter of 2026 as year[1]to-date total annuity sales reached $228.7 billion – 1% higher than the first half of 2025 − to set a new first-half record. In addition to about 7% in corporate private credit, Massaro says roughly 20% of the portfolio backing Knighthead’s annuities is in first mortgages and 30% to 40% is in public fixed income, with the rest including structured credit. The company holds almost no public equities.
“What private credit has done is allow carriers who are professional investors to use that in the portfolio construction to provide competitive rates,” says Massaro, adding that traditional annuitants put between $50,000 to $500,000 of their net worth into an annuity.
Agents and advisors aren’t always saying, ‘Let’s go for the last five basis points. Let’s go for the highest crediting rate,’” Massaro says. “What’s backing that carrier? What’s the capital backing that carrier? What’s its track record?”
“Maybe I don’t need the last five basis points. Maybe I’d rather buy something that’s very competitive, hits my income and retirement needs. But if it’s 10 or 20 basis points lower than the other carrier who I think is doing some things maybe I’m not that comfortable with, that’s what we should do. That’s where we like to play in the market.”
Knighthead Insurance Group launched in 2014 with the formation of Knighthead Annuity & Life Assurance Company in the Cayman Islands, initially offering offshore annuities before expanding into reinsurance. The group now manages about $7 billion in assets.
Knighthead entered the US market in late 2024 by acquiring Merit Life Insurance Co., which now operates under Knighthead Life. The US business wrote just under $500 million in annuity premiums in its first year and expects to reach about $1 billion this year, according to Massaro.
“We chose to make sure we were profitable working with the right tech-forward distribution partners to make the experience very pleasant,” says Massaro, adding that Knighthead distributes annuities via three to five main IMOs (Independent Marketing Organizations).
“We’ll branch out next year as we enter the bank and broker dealer channel. We’ll use some of those same independent marketing organizations to do that. Some of that we’ll do direct,” he says.
Knighthead’s international business also has a small allocation to sports investments, though Massaro says the exposure does not currently extend to its US annuity carrier.
Knighthead’s reinsurance portfolio also owns a stake in Birmingham City Football Club, the English soccer team owned by Knighthead Capital Management. Investors with minority stakes in the club include NFL icon Tom Brady.
“We think we bought it at a very attractive valuation. It’s appreciated nicely,” says Massaro. “A lot of [sports investments] tend not to have cash flow in the beginning as they grow. But if you’re matching your ALM [asset-liability management] and you’re looking at your liquidity, there’s a place in the portfolio for it.”
Brady appears alongside Knighthead Capital Management co-CEO Tom Wagner in the Brady & The Blues docuseries that debuted on Amazon Prime last year. Birmingham now plays in the second-tier Championship division of English soccer, with its stadium branded as St. Andrew’s @ Knighthead Park.
“We look at the sports industry all the time. I think there’s some excellent things to be done. They’re typically very good [investments], and they appreciate better than most other assets,” says Massaro.
Jamie Price says LPL shifted its Commonwealth target from advisors to assets, letting 16 months of growth mask departures
80% of Baby Boomers prefer guaranteed income over growth investments, yet only 17% hold an annuity, leaving protection gaps for financial advisors to close
“Even with all the work done before hand, this is still a bit stressful,” one advisor said.
Richmond-based RIA lands a 45-year-old North Carolina wealth management team as small-firm acquisitions slow nationwide
Drawing from Form 5500 filings, the platform scores 780,000 retirement plans and maps warm introductions as advisors chase the DC-to-wealth bridge
Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives
Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.