With the expiration of the second round of quantitative easing scheduled for next month, investors shouldn't assume that the fixed-income markets will respond as they did at the expiration of the first round.
It is different this time, according to Michael Souers, a mutual fund analyst at Standard & Poor's.
“At the end of QE1, the long bond rallied, but this time around, there are different sets of potential risks,” he said.
Between the end of the first quantitative easing on March 31, 2010, and Aug. 27, when
Federal Reserve Board Chairman Ben Bernanke spoke about the possibility of a second round, the S&P 500 fell 9.7% and commodities fell by 5.2%.
Conversely, the U.S. dollar was bid up 2.3% and gold rose 11.2%.
The best-performing asset class, however, was U.S. government bonds. Indeed, long-dated Treasuries gained more than 23% over the period.
“While it may be a contrarian or counterintuitive view to think that the absence of the Fed from the bond market will lead to yields' declining, that is exactly what happened when QE1 ended,” Mr. Souers said.
This time around, however, he said he thinks that the bond markets will follow a more predictable pattern that will see bond yields rise as the federal government ends its $600 billion bond-buying spree.
“It's possible that if the economy starts to lose ground and stocks start to sell off, Treasuries might rally in a flight to quality,” Mr. Souers said. “But the situations in China and Japan are different now than they were in the spring of 2010.”
With a reduced demand from Treasuries from foreign countries and a renewed emphasis from within the United States on addressing the budget deficit, Mr. Souers said that the longer-term government bonds might see yields climb due to a reduced investor appetite.
“There's a lot of caution related to investing in too-long-a-duration Treasuries,” he said.
With that in mind, Mr. Souers is highlighting three bond funds that invest in short- and intermediate-term bonds.
The American Century Government Bond Fund Ticker:(CPTBX), from
American Century Investments, has outperformed the U.S. Government Intermediate fixed-income peers over the past one-, three-, five- and 10-year periods, with a nearly 100-basis-point outperformance over the five-year period through March.
In addition, the fund's net expense ratio of 0.48% is well below the peer average of 0.98%.
Dreyfus' Bond Market Index Fund Ticker:(DBIRX) has outperformed its fixed-income peers in nine of the past 10 years, including outperforming peers by 130 basis points over the three-year period through March.
“We do note that the
index fund's new manager just took over in 2010, which detracts slightly from the fund's appeal, in our view,” according to Mr. Souers.
The Vanguard Short-Term Federal Fund Ticker:(VSGBX), offered by
The Vanguard Group Inc., is designed for investors looking to invest on the shorter end of the yield curve.
“This fund's 30-day yield of 0.82% is slightly below the peer average of 1.04%, but we think the fund's historical track record and low cost [0.22%] makes the fund attractive,” Mr. Souers said.
E-mail Jeff Benjamin at [email protected].
