When you should, or shouldn’t, recommend more protected lifetime income

When you should, or shouldn’t, recommend more protected lifetime income
Here are some of the key characteristics that may make some clients better candidates for such a solution than others.
JAN 17, 2024

Figuring out how much your clients need to save for retirement can be tricky. Figuring out how to utilize those savings to optimally fund their retirement lifestyle can be even trickier. One approach to simplifying the income generation process in retirement is to allocate savings to a product or strategy that provides income that is protected, or guaranteed, for life.

Delaying Social Security retirement benefits is one way clients can generate protected lifetime income. Understandably, the underfunded status of the Social Security trust fund and the cost of funding the bridge period may make some clients wary of this approach. 

An alternative approach to generating lifetime income would be to purchase an annuity. While early annuity products were relatively straightforward and required the irrevocable transfer of some amount (the premium) to the insurance company for some income benefit for life (often called single premium immediate annuities, or SPIAs), annuities today come in a myriad of shapes and sizes, many of which aren’t really focused on lifetime income at all. 

Interest in annuities has increased considerably in recent years in concert with the rise in interest rates, which resulted in better payouts. It's worth considering the potential role these products can play a role in a client’s retirement plan. The table below summarizes some of the key characteristics that may make some clients better candidates for a protected lifetime income product than others.

Key client characteristicsConsider more lifetime income if the client …Don’t consider more lifetime income if the client …
Income stabilityWants more income that will last, no matter how long retirement lastsIs OK funding spending through existing savings and lifetime income levels
Essential expensesHas a gap in existing lifetime income levels and essential expensesHas all essential expenses already covered with lifetime income
Funded statusHas just enough to fund retirement lifestyle, with little to no excessHas more than enough to fund spending in retirement
Health spending flexibilityIs in relatively good health, and is not OK adjusting spending levels (especially portfolio withdrawals)Is in relatively poor health and is OK adjusting spending as situations warrant
Financial decision-makingWants an automated way to generate lifetime incomeIs comfortable making financial decisions themselves
Accessing savingsIs not comfortable depleting savings given uncertain longevity and future market returnsIs comfortable spending down assets to fund retirement lifestyle
BequestsFocused on maximizing lifetime incomeInterested in leaving as much as possible to heirs
Risk toleranceIs a relatively conservative investorIs a relatively aggressive investor

Importantly, I wouldn’t make the decision to purchase lifetime income based on this table alone, since certain aspects can mean more or less to different clients. The key is thinking about how clients want to utilize their savings to achieve the best retirement possible.

If a client decides more protected lifetime income isn’t for them today, think about what would have to potentially change for them to consider it. Even if you think they would benefit from allocating to more protected lifetime income, whether it be delaying Social Security retirement benefits or buying an annuity, you don’t necessarily need to do it today. While the rise in interest rates has made the payout rates on annuities more attractive than they were a few years ago, the longevity benefits of annuities tend to increase at older ages, so waiting a few years before making a purchase (assuming that’s an option) could be the smart play.

No two clients are the same; therefore, deciding whether to allocate savings to protected lifetime income is a very personal one. The most important thing is actively addressing the topic with clients and determining which approach is best for them.

David Blanchett is head of retirement research at PGIM DC Solutions.

Retiring baby boomers forcing changes in target-date funds

Latest News

Fintech bytes: Wealth tech firms target advisor productivity with new integrations
Fintech bytes: Wealth tech firms target advisor productivity with new integrations

Amplify, WealthReach, Zeplyn and Zocks have unveiled partnerships aimed at automating portfolio management, content creation, account opening, and client communication.

Trump Account contributions to get boost from new employer rules
Trump Account contributions to get boost from new employer rules

New Treasury and IRS proposals would let employers add tax-free payroll contributions to the retirement accounts as advisors weigh the fit for client families.

Merit Financial snaps up $900M Bridgeway Group in California push
Merit Financial snaps up $900M Bridgeway Group in California push

The Atlanta-based RIA has now completed nine acquisitions in 2026, with six of those coming from Commonwealth Financial Network's former advisor base.

Generational wealth strategies are shifting as families and business owners eye Trump Accounts
Generational wealth strategies are shifting as families and business owners eye Trump Accounts

Half of small business owners want their company's success to fund generational wealth, says Guardian Life research.

Workers delaying retirement as economic anxiety grips employers
Workers delaying retirement as economic anxiety grips employers

New Principal Financial data reveals 69% of US employers say staff are postponing retirement, with inflation cited as the primary driver amid rising AI optimism.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income