Broker-dealers are failing to supervise rogue brokers, says Massachusetts regulator William Galvin

Broker-dealers are failing to supervise rogue brokers, says Massachusetts regulator William Galvin
Only 6% of reps with checkered backgrounds were placed on heightened supervision by their broker-dealers, according to a new report.
DEC 08, 2016
Broker-dealers that hire rogue brokers — those with checkered disciplinary records — are failing to properly supervise them, and could be hurting investors because of their lax self-policing standards, according to findings from a recent sweep conducted by the Massachusetts Securities Division. The division, led by Secretary of the Commonwealth William Galvin, recently conducted an examination of 241 broker-dealers registered in the state. The firms have an above-average number of reps with current misconduct reports on their records. The findings of the sweep, released Thursday, indicate few of these brokers were placed on heightened supervision, thereby exposing investors to potential harm at the hands of these rogue brokers, according to the report. “While disclosure incidents can run the gamut of allegations, and not all would necessarily mandate being place on heightened supervision, the numbers my office found raise a strong presumption that certain firms continue to hire bad brokers but are unwilling to take on the obligation of zealously monitoring their interaction with customers,” according to Mr. Galvin. The report's release coincides with a broader crackdown on rogue brokers by the Securities and Exchange Commission and its broker-dealer watchdog, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. Finra has increased its use of data to identify brokers with a record of compliance problems and who keep resurfacing at new firms, and is warning brokerages not to rehire them. In September, the SEC announced it was stepping up scrutiny of registered investment advisory firms employing brokers with disciplinary histories, to ensure they're being properly supervised. More than 40% of brokers fired because of misconduct are hired by another firm within a year, according to an academic study published in March. Prior offenders are five times as likely to engage in new misconduct, according to the study. The Massachusetts sweep, which scrutinized the two-and-a-half-year period between January 2014 and June 2016, found that while almost every brokerage had written policies vetting hired reps, more than 18% of those hired — 8,584 brokers — had disclosure incidents. In what the report calls its “most troubling finding,” of those brokers, only 6% were placed on heightened supervision — meaning 94% with disclosure incidents didn't receive heightened monitoring by their broker-dealer. Brian McNiff, a spokesman for Mr. Galvin, declined to identify which firms had the most egregious conduct. He said the study is meant to encourage the firms to self-police, and that Mr. Galvin isn't bringing action against brokerages based on the report's findings. However, the information gathered could result in more attention being paid to some of the brokerages, Mr. McNiff said. In early December, Mr. Galvin sued LPL Financial, the nation's largest independent broker-dealer, for “paper-thin compliance” regarding supervision of a top-producing broker who is alleged to have sold retirees unsuitable variable annuities.

Latest News

Summit Financial, MassMutual boost advisor appeal with growth-focused tech
Summit Financial, MassMutual boost advisor appeal with growth-focused tech

Summit Financial unveiled a suite of eight new tools, including AI lead gen and digital marketing software, while MassMutual forges a new partnership with Orion.

SEC enforcement actions drop sharply, with focus shifting to investor fraud
SEC enforcement actions drop sharply, with focus shifting to investor fraud

A new analysis shows the number of actions plummeting over a six-month period, potentially due to changing priorities and staffing reductions at the agency.

MAI inks mega-deal with Evoke Advisors to form $60B AUM firm
MAI inks mega-deal with Evoke Advisors to form $60B AUM firm

The strategic merger of equals with the $27 billion RIA firm in Los Angeles marks what could be the largest unification of the summer 2025 M&A season.

Employees tapping retirement funds amid financial strain, led by Gen Zs
Employees tapping retirement funds amid financial strain, led by Gen Zs

Report highlights lack of options for those faced with emergency expenses.

LPL Financial on target to retain 90% of Commonwealth financial advisors, Wolfe Research analyst says
LPL Financial on target to retain 90% of Commonwealth financial advisors, Wolfe Research analyst says

However, Raymond James has had success recruiting Commonwealth advisors.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.