Commission addiction holding back breakaways: Survey

Commission addiction holding back breakaways: Survey
Advisers keen on the idea of joining an RIA – but not so hot on giving up cash from transactions
DEC 02, 2011
More than half of advisers at major financial firms like the idea of becoming an RIA but many are worried about maintaining their commission income — with few willing to give it up completely, according to a recent Charles Schwab Corp. survey. It asked 210 non-RIA advisers who managed at least $10 million in client assets for their views on moving to a fee-based business model. Three out of four expect the trend of advisers leaving large firms for RIAs to continue. In fact, half of the respondents said they find the idea of becoming an RIA appealing. Advisers younger than 40 were even more interested, with 65% calling the idea appealing. The hitch? Close to 40% of the respondents said they were uncertain about how they would maintain their commission business. In fact, if they did make the switch, only 8% said they would eliminate all commission-based business. Most, around 52%, said they would hold on to at least some commission-based business, and one of out five said they would keep all commission-based business. The factors that made RIAs appealing to advisers were the potential for more income (56%), freedom to run their own business (52%) and the ability to customize client service (51%). Working against the switch was the time and effort of a transition (61%), less access to legal and compliance support (60%) and the time it would take to run a business (56%). Of note, 45% said that employee morale at their firm has gotten worse over the last five years, and about a third said income potential had dipped. But 78% said the firm's financial stability had improved or stayed the same during that time, and 83% saw an improvement or no change in firm reputation. Overall, interest in the RIA business model continues to be strong, particularly among younger advisers, said Tim Oden, senior managing director of business development at Schwab Advisor Services. "The movement to independence isn't just a flash in the pan," he said. "It's more likely to be a long-term trend.” (Dan Jamieson contributed to this report.)

Latest News

Tax-aware investing should expand client choices, not constrain them 
Tax-aware investing should expand client choices, not constrain them 

The best tax plan asks not only how much a client could save, but what they would have to give up to save it. 

Merrill veteran Jonathan Stogsdill joins Trinity Wealth Advisors in St. Louis
Merrill veteran Jonathan Stogsdill joins Trinity Wealth Advisors in St. Louis

A 20-year financial services veteran brings values-driven planning expertise to the St. Louis-based RIA.

SEC enforcement against public companies hits record low under Atkins
SEC enforcement against public companies hits record low under Atkins

New research shows a 71% plunge in actions in fiscal year 2026, with total settlements the lowest since the database began.

Edward Jones advisor launches SteadRock Private Wealth on LPL platform
Edward Jones advisor launches SteadRock Private Wealth on LPL platform

An Ohio-based advisor departs Edward Jones to build an independent firm focused on retirees and business owners.

SEC and state regulators tighten grip on fraud in fiscal 2026
SEC and state regulators tighten grip on fraud in fiscal 2026

Broker-dealer enforcement actions surged 66% as the SEC and state regulators cracked down on Ponzi schemes and digital asset fraud.

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.