Finra panel orders Raymond James to pay former broker more than $500,000 for defamation

Finra panel orders Raymond James to pay former broker more than $500,000 for defamation
Arbitrators include $100,000 sanction for firm's foot-dragging in producing documents.
SEP 17, 2019
Finra arbitrators ordered Raymond James Financial Services Inc. to pay a former broker more than $500,000 for treating her unfairly while dismissing her. The three-person, nonpublic-majority Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. arbitration panel recommended the removal of defamatory termination language in Diana Marie Petersen's Form U5. In the award document, the panel said it "portrays [her] in an extremely negative light making it quite difficult if not impossible for her to obtain new employment in the financial services industry." Ms. Petersen was given a five-day notice of termination on Oct. 27, 2015, that was to take effect on Nov.1, 2015. The amended explanation for her firing said that no reason was given and that it was not for cause. It also said she "engaged in a number of minor violations" of firm policy and "was in conflict with her supervisor." The termination explanation, as approved by the arbitrators, goes on to say that after serving her the notice of termination, Raymond James found that Ms. Petersen had signed her husband's name to a letter her husband had authorized in connection to a trust that was a Raymond James client. That was a violation of firm policy and led to her firing on Nov. 10, 2015. Ms. Petersen's actions did not involve an investment. She is no longer in the industry, according to her BrokerCheck profile. [Recommended video: Financial planning wasn't even a thing 50 years ago.] The arbitrators awarded Ms. Petersen $360,000 in compensatory damages and $1,100 in costs. They also required Raymond James to pay 10% interest per annum on the damages from Jan. 22, 2018, through Aug. 19, 2019. That added more than $50,000 to the award. The arbitrators also made Raymond James pay Ms. Petersen an additional $100,000 for violating the panel's orders to turn over documents in discovery. They were incensed by the firm's "litany of excuses" for failing to meet deadlines in producing the evidence. "The sanctions represent an indication of conduct that should not go on," said Ms. Petersen's lawyer, Michael Mahoney, a partner at Mahoney Lefky. Mr. Mahoney said Ms. Petersen could not sell her book of business of about $900,000 because of the language Raymond James used to describe her departure. He was happy with what she was able to recover through arbitration. "It's a significant victory for Diana," Mr. Mahoney said. "She is satisfied she got a fair hearing and that she needs to be paid for the damage that was done to her." A Raymond James spokesman declined to comment.

Latest News

Cerulli: Advisors struggle to turn 401(k) savers into wealth clients
Cerulli: Advisors struggle to turn 401(k) savers into wealth clients

Just over 10% of advisors' wealth clients come from defined contribution plans, as capacity, data and technology gaps block the bridge to wealth

Alto to buy Forge Trust from Schwab in self-directed IRA push
Alto to buy Forge Trust from Schwab in self-directed IRA push

Deal creates a $20B-plus custody platform for private market investing in IRAs, months after Schwab closed its Forge Global purchase

Wall Street bonanza! The Street on track to hit a record $90 billion in profits: Report
Wall Street bonanza! The Street on track to hit a record $90 billion in profits: Report

Despite the good times, advisors should tread carefully, said one veteran industry executive.

Most workers have retirement plans but no retirement strategy
Most workers have retirement plans but no retirement strategy

Gallagher data reveals a huge gap in financial confidence between employees who work with an advisor and those who don't.

Small employers are more open to pooled retirement plans
Small employers are more open to pooled retirement plans

PEP assets hit $34bn at year-end 2025 as advisors navigate mandate deadlines and a 48% employer interest rate.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.

SPONSORED In the Age of AI, Trust Becomes the Advisor's Greatest Asset

As AI makes financial information more accessible than ever, Lana Hock explains why human judgment, trust, and empathy remain the qualities clients value most in a financial advisor