How to handle clients who share Johnny Depp's alleged compulsive buying habits

Advisers offer new approaches to keeping clients within spending limits.
MAY 11, 2017

Financial advisers who have dealt with clients like Johnny Depp, an alleged compulsive spender with $2 million in monthly bills, have found methods of reforming their clients' errant shopping. Details of Mr. Depp's $30,000 monthly wine bills and other lavish expenses came out of the actor's $25 million lawsuit against his former managers. Those managers contend the impulsive star's spending is out of control. If that's true, he's not alone. About 6% of Americans are compulsive buyers, according to research published in the American Journal of Psychiatry a decade ago. And many believe the advent of online shopping has exacerbated the problem further. "Excessive spending is the number one barrier to saving for retirement," said Tia Lee, director of wealth planning at Spectrum Management Group. She has a novel approach to helping clients after years of trying to get them to simply stay within a traditional budget usually failed. Now she has compulsive spenders "budget their lives, not their money," she said. (More: Fintech to make advisers better behavioral coaches) Ms. Lee used such an approach with one woman who was racking up $12,000 a month shopping for clothes and other things online. After examining a year's worth of her spending habits revealed lots of small purchases, Ms. Lee directed her client to put as many items as she wanted in her electronic cart during the week. But the client was only allowed to purchase them on Fridays. The woman saved $5,000 a month because her own internal spending limits kicks in before she hits send on Fridays and so she removes some items from the cart before purchasing. In another case, Ms. Lee had clients who spent too much on dinners in expensive restaurants so she told them to limit their nights out to four a month. "The number of times you've been out is easier to keep track of than budgeting the amount you spend," she said. For financial adviser Lora Hoff, the key to helping out-of-control clients curb their spending is to connect the costs to something they relate to well. That requires engaging people in different ways. For one woman, a dynamic spreadsheet with her monthly and weekly spending for groceries, housing, gas, etc. and her discretionary spending did the trick. "When she plugged in her spending it would visibly reduce her availability for other items," Ms. Hoff said. "That made it a current impact instead of a future problem." (More: To help clients succeed in investing, it may require a walk down bizarro Wall Street) Other advisers said getting clients to refocus on the goals they have for their money can sometimes work to stop compulsive spending. Sometimes advisers opt for more structured approaches to spending controls. Financial adviser David Demming said he has struggled to get one of his 30-year-old clients to say no to his girlfriends' seemingly limitless expenses. "We established an irrevocable trust with his brother and sister-in-law in charge of all funds," he said. "The girls don't like him as much now!"

Latest News

WallStreetBets takes on the SEC — and makes a surprisingly sharp case
WallStreetBets takes on the SEC — and makes a surprisingly sharp case

The Reddit trading community's formal comment letter against the proposal is drawing widespread attention across finance and tech circles.

Stratos Wealth Holdings closes 11 acquisitions in push for advisory scale
Stratos Wealth Holdings closes 11 acquisitions in push for advisory scale

RIA aggregator adds $4.8 billion in client assets across seven states as demand grows for alternatives to traditional succession models.

Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human
Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management

Shareholder sues FS KKR Capital board, alleges NAV and dividend cover-up
Shareholder sues FS KKR Capital board, alleges NAV and dividend cover-up

Shareholder targets FS KKR Capital's directors over alleged portfolio valuation and dividend missteps.

UBS loses $1.2 million arbitration claim linked to variable annuities and margin
UBS loses $1.2 million arbitration claim linked to variable annuities and margin

UBS has a history of costly litigation stemming from the sale of volatile investment products.

SPONSORED Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management

SPONSORED Durability over scale: What actually defines a great advisory firm

Growth may get the headlines, but in my experience, longevity is earned through structure, culture, and discipline