ICHRA opens a new lane for advisors in employee benefits

ICHRA opens a new lane for advisors in employee benefits
Benefitbay's Brandy Thompson
Benefitbay's Brandy Thompson on why defined-contribution health benefits are becoming a conversation advisors can't afford to skip.
NOV 19, 2026

A product that lets employers set a fixed health benefits contribution, hands coverage selection to individual employees, and removes the plan sponsor from underwriting risk sounds, on paper, like something financial advisors should already be talking about with their business-owner clients.

 Most are not yet, but Brandy Thompson, co-founder and CEO of Benefitbay, thinks that is about to change and she has a pointed argument for why advisors who understand the individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement (ICHRA) will have a material advantage in the small- and mid-market employer space over the next two years.

"Employers are just having unsustainable outcomes regardless of the tool that they're pulling out of their tool chest," Thompson said. "ICHRA or CHOICE becomes a nice next-step alternative for their client."

Benefitbay operates exclusively through broker and advisor channels and serves approximately 400 companies at an average of 1,000 employees each - a deliberate focus on enterprise complexity rather than SMB volume.

A defined-contribution model for health

Financial advisors who work with employer clients on retirement plan design will find the ICHRA structure intuitive. Rather than the employer selecting and managing a group health plan - absorbing all the administrative and financial exposure that entails - the employer sets a defined monthly contribution, which employees use to purchase individual coverage on the open market.

Contributions can be tiered by geography, employment classification, full-time or part-time status, and family size, giving the employer meaningful budget control without dictating plan choice.

The parallel to defined-contribution retirement plan design is not accidental. Just as the shift from defined-benefit pension plans to 401(k)s transferred investment selection to employees while capping employer liability, ICHRA transfers health plan selection to employees while capping the employer's per-head cost exposure. For advisors already fluent in that defined-contribution framework, Thompson says ICHRA is a natural extension of the conversation.

The cost-containment mechanics are particularly relevant for advisors counseling employer clients on total compensation strategy. Under a traditional group plan, a rate increase in one geography or one high-cost claimant cohort ripples across the entire population. Under ICHRA, exposure is contained.

"Just because a 13% increase happened in a certain market does not mean that's what the employer is going to experience," Thompson said. "In group insurance or self-insurance, you have one or two things that are getting out of balance - it causes it for the whole population. In ICHRA, it's isolated."

The advisor revenue question

The concern most advisors raise about ICHRA is a familiar one from every new platform model: does year-one implementation work translate into durable year-two revenue, or does the account commoditize once it is set up?

"They're still very valuable at the table," Thompson said of advisors who stay engaged. Benefitbay provides tooling that allows advisors to benchmark new plans entering the market each year, monitor carrier movements - she cited Cigna's recent market exits as one example - and model contribution adjustments as rate environments shift. That ongoing advisory work, she argued, is where the durable revenue lives.

She also flagged a structural risk advisors should understand before choosing an ICHRA administrator: some platforms operate on referral-only agreements that expire after two years, effectively transferring the client relationship away from the originating advisor once the referral window closes.

Advisors considering an ICHRA platform partnership should review agreement terms carefully against the current compliance guidance published by the Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration before committing.

The employee empowerment case and why it matters for wealth clients

For advisors who also work with individual clients - particularly employees navigating employer benefits decisions - the ICHRA model introduces a dynamic that has not existed before in employer-sponsored health coverage: genuine, portable consumer choice.

Under a group plan, an employee's health utilization data flows into the employer's underwriting profile, shaping future plan costs for the entire workforce. Under ICHRA, that link is broken. Each employee selects their own plan on the individual market, their claims history stays with their chosen carrier, and their health data is not pooled with colleagues.

That portability has implications for financial planning conversations. An employee who selects their own ICHRA plan is effectively building a direct relationship with a carrier - one that travels with them if they change employers, as long as the new employer also offers ICHRA.

Thompson noted that dual-ICHRA households - where both spouses work for ICHRA employers - are now actively comparing their respective contributions and plan options at renewal, a behavior pattern that was not visible in the market two years ago.

The financial planning angle extends to plan tier selection. Thompson highlighted a structural problem in the current group market: high-deductible health savings account (HSA)-eligible plans, designed around the salary-deferral and tax-planning needs of higher earners, are routinely offered to entire workforces regardless of income level. For lower-wage employees, the result is deferred care.

"If we stay in HSA high-deductible health plans for a $40,000-a-year worker, they're not accessing care until they're at stage 4," she said.

For advisors who counsel clients on benefits-adjacent financial planning - HSA contribution strategy, healthcare cost modeling in retirement, or employer plan selection during job transitions - the ability to guide a client through ICHRA plan selection is a genuine value-add.

A conversation worth starting now

ICHRA is not yet a mainstream topic in most advisor practices. But the conditions driving employer interest - unsustainable group premium growth, workforce demands for portable and personalized coverage, and a maturing technology infrastructure that can handle enterprise complexity - are not cyclical.

As ICHRA scales, advisors who have already built fluency in the product will be better positioned to serve business-owner clients facing renewal pressure, individual clients navigating employer transitions, and households where both partners are actively comparing defined-contribution health options for the first time. The Kaiser Family Foundation's annual employer health benefits survey provides benchmark data on the premium cost trends making that conversation increasingly urgent.

Latest News

Advisor360 hires two execs, says LPL relationship continues after Commonwealth deal
Advisor360 hires two execs, says LPL relationship continues after Commonwealth deal

Advisor360, spun out of Commonwealth in 2019, adds two execs and is ‘excited to support LPL’ after the conversion

Pathstone’s venture bet put clients in Anthropic at a $14B valuation
Pathstone’s venture bet put clients in Anthropic at a $14B valuation

The $185 billion multi-family office’s clients got in at a $14B valuation – more than 100 times below Anthropic’s $1.5 trillion IPO

Senate passes elder fraud bill letting mutual funds pause redemptions
Senate passes elder fraud bill letting mutual funds pause redemptions

Financial Exploitation Prevention Act wins unanimous Senate approval as advisor groups press for White House signature

LPL and Ameriprise: Why can’t we be friends?
LPL and Ameriprise: Why can’t we be friends?

The two financial advice leaders announce a settlement to ongoing trade disputes involving financial advisors.

Veteran Indiana financial advisor at center of alleged $600 million Ponzi
Veteran Indiana financial advisor at center of alleged $600 million Ponzi

Phillip Patrick Williams allegedly launched the scheme in 2022 and eventually pocketed more than $100 million.

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.