Judge strikes down California board gender quota law

Judge strikes down California board gender quota law
A California law requiring that publicly held companies have a minimum number of women on their boards was struck down on May 13.
MAY 16, 2022

California corporate boards do not have to include a minimum number of women, a California Superior Court judge ruled Friday, citing a lack of a “compelling state interest.” The state failed to prove that a gender-based requirement “was necessary to improve the economy, boost opportunities for women in the workplace, and protect California taxpayers, public employees, pensions and retirees,” according to the decision.

The California law, enacted in 2018, required public companies to have at least one woman on their boards by 2019.

In her ruling, Superior Court Judge Maureen Duffy-Lewis stated that she was swayed by arguments that there were numerous avenues for supporting economic growth and opening new avenues for women, and cited a lack of credible evidence that requiring a minimum number of women on boards would directly result in the promised results of growth and equity. The reams of research documenting a correlation between a greater number of women on boards and better company performance did not prove causation, the judge ruled.

The ruling is congruent with another released on April 23, which found unconstitutional a similar quota for racial and LGBTQ diversity on the boards of California-based, publicly held companies.  

Meanwhile, in March, the European Union advanced proposed legislation that would require companies with at least 250 employees to have women occupy 40% or more of non-executive director roles, or a third of board positions, by 2027, Reuters reported.

Latest News

Advisor moves: LPL recruitment momentum continues with $815M Northwestern Mutual team
Advisor moves: LPL recruitment momentum continues with $815M Northwestern Mutual team

Meanwhile, Raymond James and Tritonpoint Partners separately welcomed father-son teams, including a breakaway from UBS in Missouri.

SEC chief Atkins signals caution on prediction market ETFs amid broader rethink of novel fund structures
SEC chief Atkins signals caution on prediction market ETFs amid broader rethink of novel fund structures

Paul Atkins has asked staff to solicit public comment on novel ETFs, pausing the clock on as many as 24 filings linked to the booming event contracts market.

Private capital's $1 trillion bet on the American retirement account
Private capital's $1 trillion bet on the American retirement account

From 401(k)s to retail funds, Deloitte sees private equity and credit crossing into mainstream investing on two fronts at once.

Advisor moves: Wells Fargo Advisors pulls in $9.6b in fresh talent during first half of May
Advisor moves: Wells Fargo Advisors pulls in $9.6b in fresh talent during first half of May

Big-name defections from Morgan Stanley, UBS, and Merrill Lynch headline a busy two weeks of recruiting for the wirehouse.

Why uncertainty is making behavioral coaching more valuable than ever
Why uncertainty is making behavioral coaching more valuable than ever

Markets have always been unpredictable. What has changed is the amount of information investors are trying to process and the growing role advisors play in helping clients avoid emotional decisions

SPONSORED Are hedge funds the missing ingredient?

Wellington explores how multi strategy hedge funds may enhance diversification

SPONSORED Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management