Knut Rostad: Trump adviser Anthony Scaramucci should apologize for DOL fiduciary rule remarks

'Dred Scott' comments by the SkyBridge Capital executive 'are so at odds with the DOL rule, law, logic and basic human decency, they demand a rebuke.'
OCT 21, 2016
We reached out to Anthony Scaramucci on Wednesday and invited him to discuss his recent remarks regarding the DOL fiduciary rule in a webinar. At the time of this writing, we have not heard from him or his office, so can only conclude he has chosen to decline the invitation. [After this blog was published, Knut Rostad said Mr. Scaramucci's office contacted him, expressing interest in debating the issue. InvestmentNews will relay the details of such an event once it is scheduled.] The remarks of the Donald Trump adviser and SkyBridge Capital executive on the Labor Department's fiduciary rule are so at odds with the DOL rule, law, logic and basic human decency, they demand a rebuke. Equating established notions of fiduciary restraint with the deplorable institution of human bondage — suggesting that serving clients' best interest amounts to slavery — is beyond the pale.    The remarks were reported in InvestmentNews on Tuesday. Mr. Scaramucci asserted that the DOL “has made a decision to discriminate against a class of people who they deem to be adding no value … judging what should happen in a free market and attempting to put advisers out of work.” The logic of Mr. Scaramucci's remarks is not just off base, it's upside down. The DOL rule generally applies a fiduciary standard to both classes of financial advisers: brokers and registered investment advisers advising on retirement accounts. It increases fiduciary protections to one of the most vulnerable segments in society: retirement investors. Further, it permits a broker or adviser to continue offering conflicted advice if, and only if, the conflict can be mitigated and any higher costs can be justified to be in the best interest of the client. (More: The most up-to-date information on the DOL fiduciary rule) Consequently, the DOL rule “discriminates” — not against a “class of people” — but against a “class” of conduct and practices that result in conflicts and higher costs. And research indicates beyond a doubt that institutional and retail investors increasingly reject unjustified higher costs. The DOL rule, then, simply reflects the demand of the market place, rather than either overriding or steering it. Mr. Scaramucci's rhetoric, particularly at a moment when so much negative discourse fills the airways, either speaks to where language standards have landed in 2016, or that his remarks are a one-off mistake. Mr. Scaramucci has a choice. He can overlook the terrible nature of his remarks and do nothing, or he can reconsider them and apologize. The latter would be the easier route. Recognizing he erred in raising the specter of slavery should not be a hard decision. He should apologize to advisers who work to help investors retire with dignity. He should do so not just for his own good but for the good of those who work diligently and honorably in finance — as well as for the good of young people who may be considering career options in finance and financial planning. The young people in his firm and in his life who look to him for guidance may appreciate he do so as well. Knut Rostad is co-founder and president of the Institute for the Fiduciary Standard.

Latest News

Finra's Reg BI Enforcement: Is it 'ineffective, costly'?
Finra's Reg BI Enforcement: Is it 'ineffective, costly'?

The industry watchdog's own reports reflect failures to deter "willful" and "repeat" violations, raising a crucial question about the future of regulation.

SEC prepares to back away from defending climate rule in court
SEC prepares to back away from defending climate rule in court

Acting Chairman Mark Uyeda directed SEC staff to initiate a pause in court while the commission awaits a quorum. The SEC may decide to withdraw from defending itself in a lawsuit over last year's climate disclosure rule.

wealth.com welcomes Kathy Wunderli in private wealth push
wealth.com welcomes Kathy Wunderli in private wealth push

The top estate planning platform's veteran hire will lead its legal team's efforts to develop estate planning, tax analysis, and wealth transfer solutions for ultra-high-net-worth clients.

Morgan Stanley loses $843,000 investor claim stemming from 'gold bar' scam
Morgan Stanley loses $843,000 investor claim stemming from 'gold bar' scam

“If Morgan Stanley had called my client’s son, this wouldn’t have happened,” the investor's attorney said.

LPL welcomes $630M sibling advisor duo from Corebridge
LPL welcomes $630M sibling advisor duo from Corebridge

Meanwhile, Ameriprise has bolstered its own ranks as an LPL defector joins its branch channel in California.

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.

SPONSORED Why wealth advisors should care about the future of federal tax policy

Blue Vault features expert strategies to harness for maximum client advantage.