New study shows advisors choosing SMAs over model portfolios

New study shows advisors choosing SMAs over model portfolios
Fewer financial advisors expect to increase allocations to model investment portfolios over the next year, opting for SMAs instead.
FEB 06, 2024

Models are growing less super lately – at least when it comes to advisor investment portfolios.

According to data released Tuesday from analytics and advisory firm Escalent Financial Services, fewer financial advisors expect to increase allocations in model investment portfolios over the next year, but instead are opting for separately managed accounts. The report attributes this shift to advisors seeking increased customization and their desire to align investment strategies with client expectations.

“The extent to which advisors employ model portfolios and SMAs has the potential to significantly impact how asset managers operate within the wealth management industry,” Meredith Lloyd Rice, vice president at Escalent, said in a statement.

The report showed only one in five (22 percent) advisors anticipates relying more on model portfolios in the next year, a five-percentage-point drop from 2022. Concerns about underperformance and fees, in addition to the demand for greater customization and increased fund options, are behind the stalling growth of model portfolios, the report said.

Meanwhile, the study shows advisors anticipate substantial increases in their SMA holdings over the next two years, with average allocations projected to reach 26 percent in 2025, up from 18 percent currently. The report revealed that this trend is even more pronounced among advisors serving high-net-worth clients, who expect their average allocations to climb from 23 percent in 2023 to 31 percent in 2025.

“Despite expectations that advisor reliance on model portfolios would grow, we’re seeing a leveling off in adoption,” Lloyd Rice said. “Advisors are reevaluating whether model portfolios offer the performance and sophistication their more affluent clients demand.”

Despite the fact that only three in 10 (29 percent) advisors using model portfolios reported increasing their use over the last year, those who did reportedly said they appreciated “having more time to focus on engaging with clients and building relationships.”

“For advisors serving high-net-worth clients, customization and tax management is key, and this is one of the factors fueling the growth of SMAs and direct indexing,” Lloyd Rice added.

Commission-free annuity transactions are on the rise. Here's why

Latest News

SEC and state regulators tighten grip on fraud in fiscal 2026
SEC and state regulators tighten grip on fraud in fiscal 2026

Broker-dealer enforcement actions surged 66% as the SEC and state regulators cracked down on Ponzi schemes and digital asset fraud.

Marsh acquires Wilshire to deepen wealth advisor reach
Marsh acquires Wilshire to deepen wealth advisor reach

The deal adds $221 billion in AUM and bolsters Marsh's alternatives and model portfolio capabilities for advisors.

Gen X retirement savings facing ‘collision of financial pressures’ from family obligations
Gen X retirement savings facing ‘collision of financial pressures’ from family obligations

New Jackson research finds multi-generational financial obligations are leaving pre-retirees dangerously off track.

Osaic CEO Jamie Price sees W-2 channel growing to a third of assets
Osaic CEO Jamie Price sees W-2 channel growing to a third of assets

Osaic's Empowered Independence reached roughly $20 billion in a year and a half as succession pressure pushes advisors toward becoming W-2 employees

TaxStatus, Nitrogen plug into Claude and ChatGPT in advisor AI push
TaxStatus, Nitrogen plug into Claude and ChatGPT in advisor AI push

New connectors bring IRS data. planning workflows, and meeting intelligence into AI assistants as RIAs make AI integration a top growth investment

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.