Performance-based pay may lead to problems including fines — and even a tarnished brand

Nobel prize winners studied performance-based compensation practices reported back a cautionary tale.
OCT 23, 2016
By  Ellie Zhu
Paying staff based on how well they perform makes a lot of sense. Or does it? Two professors who won the Nobel Prize for Economic Sciences earlier this month studied performance-based compensation practices — and reported back a cautionary tale. Yes, incentives can motivate the right employees, but depending how metrics are designed and calculated, they can encourage disastrous behavior — and the firm will ultimately pay big, sometimes with fines, other times with a tarnished brand. Think Wells Fargo, where thousands of employees opened fake customer accounts to boost their own sales numbers and rake in higher bonuses — the costs and headaches to clients be damned. The extent of the damage to Wells Fargo is inestimable at this point, but it's safe to say it'll be huge and reverberate to other areas of its business. Think Morgan Stanley, which was charged in Massachusetts with conducting an unethical sales contest in which financial advisers were incentivized to get clients to take loans against their investment accounts. Even pay based on performance outside of sales targets can prove troublesome. As InvestmentNews reporter Liz Skinner found in her story on the Nobel winners' work and how it relates to advisers, compensation tied to performance can deter managers from giving bad reviews — even when deserved. As Philip Palaveev, CEO of The Ensemble Practice, noted that in these instances the firms' costs rise because employees are paid at a level above what is justified relative to the productivity of coworkers. He also said it could inspire the fudging of data to shift, for example, the onboarding of clients into a quarter that fits the adviser versus reality. (More: How to calculate a fair salary for a new hire) “In the absence of proper management and a good culture, performance-based compensation can fail miserably,” Mr. Palaveev said. The lesson seems to be that performance is subjective, and it needs to be gauged in that light. Tying pay or bonuses squarely to figures that can be manipulated is a sure route to trickery that will not deliver a positive return on investment to a firm.

Latest News

Retirement delays, Social Security fears prompt advisors to rethink income strategies
Retirement delays, Social Security fears prompt advisors to rethink income strategies

Concerns about outliving savings and healthcare costs are reshaping how "Peak 65" Americans and advisors approach income planning.

Merrill Lynch on the hook for $3.7M after clients claimed sale of unsuitable private equity
Merrill Lynch on the hook for $3.7M after clients claimed sale of unsuitable private equity

Some investors recently have seen million dollar plus decisions by FINRA arbitration panels involving complex products decisions go their way.

Barred ex-Merrill Lynch advisor arrested in alleged $2.6M theft of former Miami Dolphin Pro Bowler
Barred ex-Merrill Lynch advisor arrested in alleged $2.6M theft of former Miami Dolphin Pro Bowler

Former advisor Isaiah Williams allegedly used the stolen funds from ex-Dolphins defensive safety Reshad Jones for numerous personal expenses, according to police and court records.

RIA moves: Modern Wealth tops $8.5B AUM as Aspen expands in Connecticut
RIA moves: Modern Wealth tops $8.5B AUM as Aspen expands in Connecticut

Modern Wealth's latest deal for a California-based fee-only RIA marks its fourth acquisition of 2025.

Empower defends private market access in 401(k)s in response to Warren scrutiny
Empower defends private market access in 401(k)s in response to Warren scrutiny

Sen. Warren has warned of private market investment risks due to opacity, illiquidity, and past regulatory issues.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.