SEC warns industry against marketing rule pitfalls

SEC warns industry against marketing rule pitfalls
An alert from the regulator details problems it found in firms' compliance procedures, advertising practices, and Form ADV disclosures.
APR 19, 2024

Advisors and firms wrestling with the SEC’s marketing rule now have a little more clarity. The agency has released a summary of findings from examinations related to its marketing rule, revealing both progress and significant missteps by financial advisers in adhering to the guidelines.

The risk alert from the Securities and Exchange Commission's Division of Examinations shows that while many advisers strive to comply with the rule, several concerning practices persist.

The findings point to numerous instances of noncompliance, ranging from unsubstantiated claims to misleading advertising tactics, raising concerns about the transparency and accuracy of information available to investors.

"Advisers generally included Marketing Rule processes in their compliance policies," the SEC noted, acknowledging the efforts made by many firms to follow the rule.

However, the division also reported common shortcomings in policies and procedures around marketing rule compliance. These gaps include using broad descriptions rather than specific guidelines, a lack of coverage for all marketing channels, and policies that the regulator said were overly informal or outdated.

The alert also raised alarms on untrue statements and misleading information within advertisements. Among several examples, the SEC pointed to advisors claiming to be "free of all conflicts" when actual conflicts existed, and misrepresentations about the advisors' qualifications and services.

Some advisors also went offside by playing up the nature of their investment processes or services, the regulator said, with claims that they adhere to nonexistent ethical standards or falsely stating that they follow ESG investment mandates.

The SEC flagged cases of firms misusing its logo and taking its name in vain, with advertisements that went “beyond factual statements [about an advisor’s] registration status ... to imply that SEC registration was representative of a particular level of skill or ability.”

The alert emphasized deficiencies related to the preservation of advertisement-related documents, with some advisors “not [maintaining] copies of information posted to social media," and "not [maintaining] documentation to support performance claims included in advertisements.”

The examinations also revealed deficiencies in Form ADV filings, specifically around advisors’ advertising practices, including failing to disclose their use of third-party ratings to promote themselves, and not declaring when they used hypothetical or actual performance results in their marketing materials and ads.

“The [Division of Examinations] encourages advisers to reflect upon their own practices, policies, and procedures and to implement any appropriate modifications to their training, supervisory, oversight, and compliance programs,” the SEC said.

The SEC has made compliance with the marketing rule a regulatory priority, sending a strong signal to the industry last week with an enforcement sweep that caught five firms.

ESG debate not dulling investor demand, says Janus Henderson strategist

Latest News

IRA assets swell to $19.2 trillion as 401(k) rollovers drive growth
IRA assets swell to $19.2 trillion as 401(k) rollovers drive growth

IRAs now hold nearly twice the assets of 401(k) plans — and most of that money didn't arrive through annual contributions.

Women feel confident about saving, but many still keep cash in low-yield accounts
Women feel confident about saving, but many still keep cash in low-yield accounts

A new survey finds that many women prioritize financial security but continue to leave savings in accounts that may not keep pace with inflation.

SEC seeks comment on prediction-market ETFs after May pause
SEC seeks comment on prediction-market ETFs after May pause

Roundhill, Bitwise and GraniteShares funds remain on hold while the agency weighs how novel ETFs should be regulated.

Dump investment banks, buy alternative asset managers, says Oppenheimer
Dump investment banks, buy alternative asset managers, says Oppenheimer

"Shares of alternative assets managers have lagged this year as investors grow wary of private-credit exposure."

TaxStatus rolls out rules-based tool to flag advice gaps
TaxStatus rolls out rules-based tool to flag advice gaps

The fintech platform is touting a new AI-free Planning Observations feature, which draws on IRS tax records to uncover opportunities for advisors.

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income

SPONSORED Why direct indexing stopped being optional

Direct indexing is on pace to outgrow ETFs and mutual funds. Northern Trust's Ken Lassner explains why the advisors who get it wish they had started sooner.