Supreme Court ruling on SEC judges unlikely to upend advice industry

Supreme Court ruling on SEC judges unlikely to upend advice industry
But it could give rise to new hearings for some advisers who are already in litigation with the agency such as Dawn Bennett.
JUN 21, 2018

The Supreme Court's ruling on Thursday against the Securities and Exchange Commission could help some financial advisers who are currently engaged in legal battles with the agency, but will likely have little impact on new cases, according to securities lawyers. The high court, in a 7-2 decision, sided with former investment adviser Raymond J. Lucia, who said the SEC's appointment process for its in-house judges, called administrative law judges, was unconstitutional. Mr. Lucia's counsel, Mark Perry of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher, said the ruling validated that his client was "the victim of an unconstitutional proceeding." When bringing a lawsuit against financial advisers, the SEC may do so before one of its five in-house judges rather than a federal judge in district court. Critics argue this tinges the proceedings with a level of bias in favor of the SEC. Legal experts don't believe the Supreme Court's ruling will have a broad effect on the use of administrative law judges — the ruling didn't challenge the judges' overall constitutionality, just the constitutionality of the process by which the judges are appointed. "In the biggest picture, it doesn't change anything," said Kenneth Berg, a partner at Ulmer & Berne. "There are still going to be sanctions imposed by administrative law judges." The Supreme Court said the constitution requires in-house judges to be appointed by the president, a department head (i.e., the SEC commissioners) or a court. In November, the SEC took the step of ratifying the appointment of its in-house judges, which experts believe cleared them to hear new SEC cases without it being unconstitutional. "This decision wouldn't affect a proceeding that hasn't happened yet," said Ira Matetsky, partner at Ganfer & Shore, speaking of the Supreme Court ruling. "It will have an impact on some present or past proceedings." The proceedings that would likely be most impacted are those currently pending and in which advisers raised a question about the constitutionality of administrative law judges, legal experts said. One high-profile example: financial adviser Dawn J. Bennett, who wanted her case heard in federal court rather than before an in-house SEC judge; she skipped out on the SEC's administrative hearing rather than defend herself. Her case, Bennett v. SEC, is currently pending before the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals. "I do think this is a victory for anyone who's raised the issue and questioned if proceedings were constitutionally valid," said Gregory Morvillo, Ms. Bennett's former attorney and a partner at the law firm Orrick. There are roughly 100 cases pending before the SEC and more than 10 pending in appellate courts, said Mr. Perry, who defended Mr. Lucia in the Supreme Court hearing. The SEC had barred Mr. Lucia from the industry in 2013 and fined him $300,000 for allegedly misleading claims about his "buckets of money" retirement investing strategy. Mr. Perry also expects legal challenges from financial advisers who hadn't previously raised the issue of in-house-judge constitutionality, by arguing that their constitutional rights had been violated. "My guess is at least a few people will take a run at it," he said. However, he acknowledged it's likely an "uphill battle."

Latest News

Five-person Raymond James team jumps to Janney in Maryland
Five-person Raymond James team jumps to Janney in Maryland

The group led by a 37-year industry veteran brings $470 million in assets to the Philadelphia-based broker dealer.

$20B Merit looks to next phase as Constellation takes minority stake
$20B Merit looks to next phase as Constellation takes minority stake

The Atlanta, Georgia-based national wealth firm revealed its new PE partner as prior backers Wealth Partners Capital Group and HGGC’s Aspire Holdings exited their investments.

$350M father-son duo hops from Osaic to Equitable Advisors
$350M father-son duo hops from Osaic to Equitable Advisors

The latest departures in Ohio mark another setback for the hybrid RIA, which is looking to "expanding its presence across all models and segments of the wealth management industry.”

Fresh off HPS acquisition, BlackRock inks deal for $7.3B ElmTree Funds
Fresh off HPS acquisition, BlackRock inks deal for $7.3B ElmTree Funds

The St. Louis-based real estate investment firm gives the asset management giant a valuable access point to the roughly $1 trillion net lease market.

SEC charges Chicago-based investment adviser with overbilling clients more than $2.5M in fees
SEC charges Chicago-based investment adviser with overbilling clients more than $2.5M in fees

Eliseo Prisno, a former Merrill advisor, allegedly collected unapproved fees from Filipino clients by secretly accessing their accounts at two separate brokerages.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.