California voters have turned down the nation's first statewide wealth tax on billionaires, but advisors to wealthy families say the threat has not gone away – and that selling appreciated assets to get ahead of the next proposal could cost clients more than the tax itself.
Proposition 40 failed 52.8% to 47.2% this past Election Day. The measure would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on Californians worth more than $1 billion, and its union backers have vowed to try again in 2028. A week earlier, Washington voters went the other way, rejecting Initiative 645's bid to repeal the state's new 9.9% tax on income above $1 million. That levy is on track to take effect in 2028, Bloomberg Tax reported, though a constitutional challenge is pending.
For financial advisors, that split result means the planning questions raised by Prop 40 are here to stay. The advisors interviewed by InvestmentNews agree on the first answer: don't restructure a portfolio around a bill nobody has read.
Kylie Allen, executive vice president of Fractional Family Office at 49 Financial, said a proposal that hasn't passed is a weak reason to liquidate anything. Selling a low-basis stock or real estate position locks in capital gains tax today to avoid a tax that may never exist, she said, before trading costs and time out of the market are counted.
There is a less visible cost, too. A sale gives up the step-up in basis at death – the rule that resets an inherited asset's cost basis to its market value when the owner dies, which can erase decades of embedded gains for heirs.
Allen draws a line, however, between waiting and ignoring the fine print. "Proposals differ in how they set the measurement date and test residency," she said. Prop 40, for instance, would have applied to billionaires living in California on Jan. 1, 2026, and measured their net worth as of Dec. 31, 2026, with payments allowed in installments over five years. "Courts may also narrow or block a tax after passage, which is another reason why they may not want to restructure on a headline," Allen said.
Jim Claypool, team lead and wealth manager at Coldstream Wealth Management and team lead and partner at Coldstream Tax Consulting, called any reallocation now premature. "The failure of the proposal in California will force any state to re-evaluate such a proposal and, as such, there is no way to reasonably anticipate what any such proposal would look like," he said. "Incurring the cost and potential opportunity cost of reallocating now would not seem like a prudent approach."
Kelly Milligan, managing partner at Quorum Private Wealth, part of Sanctuary Wealth, agreed that wealth tax proposals on their own should not trigger allocation changes. He argued tax efficiency should already be standard practice. "I do think that taxes are often the largest bills our clients pay and therefore portfolios should always be managed with an eye towards tax efficiency," Milligan said. That means asset location, or holding tax-inefficient assets inside qualified accounts, and "tax alpha," a theme that has pushed more firms toward integrating wealth management and tax services.
What does make sense, Allen said, is a quieter review of concentration and liquidity. "If 70 - 80% of someone's net worth is in one private company or a handful of illiquid positions, that was a concentration problem before anyone talked about wealth taxes," she said. "A wealth tax would simply make the cash flow squeeze more obvious."
How much it hurts depends on the design. A one-time levy such as California's is mostly a financing problem, particularly if it can be paid over several years, Allen said, while an annual tax on accumulated wealth is a permanent drag. Her hardest case is the founder of a closely held business, or the long-time holder of low-basis stock, who owes a bill on value that can't easily be turned into cash.
She starts with three conversations: who values the holding, where the money to pay would come from and whether the ownership structure still fits. "Valuation disputes are where these taxes get ugly, so clean, current appraisals and good records matter," Allen said. Funding options include distributions, a credit line against the assets or selling a slice over time, each with a cost worth knowing in advance.
She also favors building flexibility now: holding some liquidity, keeping new investments from adding to the illiquid pile without a reason and, where the portfolio supports it, using tax-loss harvesting or direct indexing – owning an index's individual stocks in a separate account so losses can be harvested to offset future gains. "A plan on paper costs nothing, and it lets us move in weeks instead of scrambling," she said.
Allen argues the same exercise doubles as estate planning. If a founder died unexpectedly, the family could face a large tax bill on an illiquid business with no easy source of cash. "This is the same conversation we should already be having about estate tax," she said. "The estate planning work is the exception. It pays off whether or not a wealth tax ever passes."
Claypool said cash flow was one of the flaws in California's design. "Liquidity is certainly an issue with any tax on wealth or net worth, and any future legislation would need to address this issue," he said.
Milligan expects the compliance burden of any tax on unrealized gains – appraisals, valuations, assessments and discounts – to be high. If a wealth tax were seriously considered, he said, advisors should work closely with estate planning attorneys to determine which options apply. "These might include putting assets into LLCs or Trusts and taking a discount on valuation for lack of marketability or lack of control," Milligan said. "In my opinion there are far better ways to tax the wealthy without creating all of the downstream effects."
When Prop 40 was in the news, the question Allen heard most was whether clients should leave the state. Some will, she said, while family, business and preference will keep others in place. She noted that states counting on new revenue tend to treat departures as an afterthought. "The revenue estimates behind these proposals assume the taxpayers stay," Allen said – a risk underscored when a Stanford analysis found the billionaire tax may shrink state revenue.
For clients who do relocate, the move has to be real. "Keeping the house, the doctors, and the social life while claiming a new address is a common way to lose an audit," Allen said. "A move doesn't always end the exposure either." Income from property or businesses tied to the old state usually remains taxable there, and some proposals test residency on a date that may already have passed – one reason some California RIAs began drafting exit plans as the measure gained traction.
Claypool said migration is already under way in Washington, where Bloomberg Tax reported the new levy would affect roughly 30,000 people. "Well beyond the high profile executives and founders, this migration is causing people with net worth as low as $3 million to $6 million to move and is going to have a significant effect on the tax base of the state," he said. "States like Arizona, which has worked its income tax down to an essentially flat 2.5%, or the few states that remain with zero income tax, will continue to see migration of entrepreneurs into their states."
Milligan agreed. "Nobody is more geographically mobile than the wealthy. They can and will make decisions that consider relative tax burdens," he said. "They will also demand ever more tax alpha from the investment vehicles in their portfolio."
That demand calls for discipline, Allen cautioned. Trusts and certain insurance structures may draw fresh interest, but a product sold mainly on fear of a law that doesn't exist yet is usually a poor fit, she said. "If a structure only works under legislation that has not passed, it is probably too early." Claypool expects new vehicles to follow any law that does pass, "but they will be structured in the context of the new tax and as we said before, nobody knows what that will look like."
Allen's advice to advisors is to be candid that the rules are still a guess. "So the goal now is to gather information and shorten our reaction time, not to restructure around a bill nobody has read," she said.
New wealth, evolving donor expectations, and responsible AI are reshaping charitable planning for advisors.
Bridge Operating Partners debuts with deep industry pedigree and a proprietary AI system designed to sharpen decision-making for wealth firm executives.
Two San Clemente teams leave LPL for Osaic while a Delray Beach trio departs Ameriprise for Raymond James’s independent advisor channel
Osaic’s Form ADV says majority owner Reverence Capital’s stake in Envestnet gives the firm and its advisors an incentive to recommend Envestnet programs. Reverence and Bain Capital backs both firms.
Treasury’s final SECURE 2.0 regulations give plan sponsors flexibility, though Vanguard calls for existing plans to face the mandate too.
Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives
Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.