Where key players align in the DOL fiduciary fight

As the proposal's comment period ends Tuesday, here's a snapshot of some of the larger parties' stances.
JUL 23, 2015
For
Against
For
Against
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100530720.PNG"
AARP
Rule would reduce bad investment advice that costs retirement savers $17 billion annually.
"Consumers deserve advice in their best interests, not advice that benefits the adviser." — Nancy LeaMond,  chief advocacy and engagement officer
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100533720.PNG"
Financial Planning Coalition (CFP Board, FPA, NAPFA)
Rule would help reduce client confusion about whether an adviser must act in their best interests. FPC will seek clarification of education versus advice and a reduction of disclosure and reporting requirements.
"This reform is long overdue."— Marilyn Mohrman-Gillis,  managing director for public policy and communications at the CFP Board of Standards Inc.
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100536720.PNG"
Consumer Federation of America
Rule sets out specific ways firms and brokers must act as fiduciaries.
"It doesn't just give lip service to best interests." — Barbara Roper,  director of consumer protection
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100538720.PNG"
President Barack Obama
Rule would help reduce conflicts of interest that cause brokers to steer clients into high-fee products.
"The goal here is to put an end to Wall Street brokers who benefit from backdoor payments or hidden fees at the expense of their clients."
Against
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100540720.PNG"
Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association
Giving and receiving retirement advice would become significantly more expensive under the rule.
"In the end, the very same investors the [Labor] Department seeks to protect would likely inadvertently be harmed with limited choices." — Kenneth E. Bentsen Jr.,  president and chief executive, in July 20 comment letter
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100541720.PNG"
Financial Services Institute
Best-interests contract exemption is a complex, costly disclosure obligation.
"The current rule as written is unworkable."— Dale Brown,  president and chief executive
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100544720.PNG"
Rule would cause firms to abandon brokerage for fee-based business model.
"I fear that the uncertainties stemming from contractual analysis and the shortage of useful guidance will lead many firms to close their IRA business."— Richard Ketchum,  chairman and chief executive
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100545720.PNG"
National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors
Rule's best-interests contract would intimidate clients and significantly raise adviser costs.
"Many [firms] may have no choice but to shift their business to wealthier clients who can afford higher fees or to leave the retirement space altogether."— Juli McNeely,  president
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100547720.PNG"
U.S. Chamber of Commerce
Rule would make it more difficult and costly for small businesses to offer retirement plans.
"Nine million small-business-supported households will either completely lose access to employer-sponsored retirement plans or face dramatically higher fees."— David Hirschmann,  president and chief executive, Center for Capital Markets Competitiveness
/assets/docs src="/wp-content/uploads2015/07/CI100546720.PNG"
Insured Retirement Institute
Rule would curb investor choice in the type of adviser they use.
"We have concerns about the application of this rule and the consequences it will have on retirement savers."— Lee Covington,  senior vice president and general counsel

Latest News

Vanilla, WealthFeed land new RIA partnerships
Vanilla, WealthFeed land new RIA partnerships

Vanilla is extending its estate planning tech to Callan Family Office's ultra-high-net-worth business, while WealthFeed's organic growth engine will now be available to roughly 100 advisors at The Mather Group.

As Trump Accounts prep for July 4 launch, Franklin Templeton plans $1,000 match
As Trump Accounts prep for July 4 launch, Franklin Templeton plans $1,000 match

“We are helping families take an important first step toward building a financial foundation for the next generation,” said Franklin Templeton CEO Jenny Johnson

Savant Wealth Management enters Maine with latest acquisition
Savant Wealth Management enters Maine with latest acquisition

Richard Brothers Financial Advisors joins the fee-only RIA, adding its first Maine office and $240 million in client assets

Clearstead adds $5.3B Philadelphia wealth team from myCIO
Clearstead adds $5.3B Philadelphia wealth team from myCIO

Cleveland RIA grows to $68 billion in assets as Philadelphia team, deepening its high-net-worth and retirement-plan practice.

Advisors still have questions on Trump Accounts ahead of July 4 launch
Advisors still have questions on Trump Accounts ahead of July 4 launch

Financial planning leaders say unresolved rules on fees, Roth conversions and financial aid complicate comparisons with 529 plans.

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income

SPONSORED Why direct indexing stopped being optional

Direct indexing is on pace to outgrow ETFs and mutual funds. Northern Trust's Ken Lassner explains why the advisors who get it wish they had started sooner.