Finra: Make broker-dealers disclose 'shelf space'

Finra wants broker-dealers to disclose the revenue-sharing deals they have with mutual funds
MAY 15, 2011
Finra wants broker-dealers to disclose the revenue-sharing deals they have with mutual funds. General information on these “shelf space” payments is already disclosed in funds' prospectuses and related documents, but the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. wants broker-dealers themselves to offer customers a toll-free number or website for similar disclosures. Finra this month filed a rule change with the Securities and Exchange Commission that would make this type of disclosure mandatory for brokerage firms. The rule proposal, which includes other provisions as well, was published in the Federal Register May 9. It would amend and adopt the old NASD Rule 2830, which covers mutual funds, as Finra Rule 2341. Comments are due by May 31. Some broker-dealers already disclose which funds they have deals with and the maximum amount any one fund company would pay. Under the Finra proposal, member firms “would have to prominently disclose that this additional cash compensation may influence the selection of investment company securities that the member and its associated persons offer or recommend to investors,” according to Finra's SEC filing. Brokerage firms would have to “provide a prominent reference ... to a web page or toll-free telephone number where the investor could obtain additional information concerning these arrangements,” according to the filing. The proposal stems from a controversial notice Finra published in 2009. Industry interests told Finra then that the increased disclosures would conflict with other pending rules and would be confusing for investors.

FIGHT OVER REQUIREMENT

Finra disagreed. Requiring revenue-sharing disclosures by firms would “further inform investors of the potential conflicts that can arise from the sale of” mutual funds, the regulator said in its filing. “The Finra proposal appears to be a stopgap measure until the SEC addresses the broader issue of whether advisers must act in their clients' best interests,” said Louis Harvey, president of Dalbar Inc., a fund research firm. Under the Dodd-Frank law, the SEC is working on rulemaking to expand a fiduciary duty to brokers. That standard of care likely would include increased disclosures about a variety of conflicts and products. Mr. Harvey worries that singling out mutual funds now for heightened disclosure of revenue sharing might prejudice investors against buying funds. Under a broader fiduciary duty, “this and every other potential conflict of interest must be disclosed [and] all investments [put] on a level playing field,” Mr. Harvey said. Revenue-sharing deals vary by firm and fund. Specific amounts that a fund pays a broker-dealer are not usually disclosed. Finra's proposal would not require specific disclosure. Critics of the payments have complained that the actual amounts paid are material and should be transparent. Edward Jones is one of the few, if not the only, firms to disclose the percentage of assets paid by individual fund companies. Jones gets from 2.9 basis points on assets from the American Funds, up to 13 basis points from other fund companies, all of which do less volume than American Funds. Edward Jones' detailed disclosures were mandated under a settlement with the SEC in 2004. E-mail Dan Jamieson at [email protected].

Latest News

Gen Z, Millennials shape the new rules of financial advice but can advisors keep up?
Gen Z, Millennials shape the new rules of financial advice but can advisors keep up?

Kristy Smith from Broadridge says advisors who can't adapt risk being left behind.

Americans share confusion, concerns ahead of Social Security's 90th anniversary
Americans share confusion, concerns ahead of Social Security's 90th anniversary

Surveys show continued misconceptions and pessimism about the program, as well as bipartisan support for reforms to sustain it into the future.

The advisor’s essential role as alternative investments go mainstream
The advisor’s essential role as alternative investments go mainstream

With doors being opened through new legislation and executive orders, guiding clients with their best interests in mind has never been more critical.

Advisor moves: Raymond James snags advisor teams from RBC, Wells Fargo, Thrivent
Advisor moves: Raymond James snags advisor teams from RBC, Wells Fargo, Thrivent

Meanwhile, Stephens lures a JPMorgan advisor in Louisiana, while Wells Fargo adds two wirehouse veterans from RBC.

Private equity’s courtship of retail investors irks pensions, endowments
Private equity’s courtship of retail investors irks pensions, endowments

Large institutions are airing concerns that everyday investors will cut into their fee-bargaining power and stakeholder status, among other worries.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.