Focus on outcomes, not mythical legal jargon, says Finseca CEO

Focus on outcomes, not mythical legal jargon, says Finseca CEO
Marc Cadin responds to a recent InvestmentNews editorial and explains why he believes the DOL process and pro-fiduciary rule argument are both flawed.
MAY 21, 2024

If the final version of the Retirement Security Rule stoked the fire within Marc Cadin, the CEO of Finseca, the subsequent InvestmentNews editorial fanned the flames.

In a phone interview, the leader of an organization that represents more than 9,000 financial security professionals who provide life insurance and retirement planning solutions, criticized the Department of Labor’s process, which he again branded “unAmerican”, took aim at those who think being a fiduciary always leads to better outcomes for consumers, and said this publication’s editorial, headlined “Fiduciary commitment should be table stakes”, was based on a “flawed premise.”

He also said he will be recommending litigation against the new rule to his board and, personally, believes it will be successful.

The Department of Labor’s new fiduciary rule will for the first time subject many agents selling annuities to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, holding them to the legal fiduciary standard of advice.

InvestmentNews stands by its editorial and its stance on the rule. But as a platform for news and views from across the industry, is open to debate and willing to offer Cadin a right of reply.

In doing so, Cadin explained his belief that the argument for the fiduciary rule, as set out by InvestmentNews and other proponents, mistakenly focuses on legal jargon instead of outcomes for consumers.

“The table stakes, if you will, should be how we increase the financial security of the American people,” he said. “That should be everybody's objective. It should be the Department of Labour’s objective, it should be [InvestmentNews’] objective, it should be the industry's objective.

“In our opinion, [consumers] become more financially secure when they get the products and the advice they need. It’s both. It's not just advice; it's not just products. We need to create a behavior among more Americans to save earlier and save in the right ways.”

Cadin cited an Ernst & Young study in 2021 he says showed how consumers get better outcomes, and save better, when they combine permanent life insurance, investments and annuities.

He added: “Let’s really focus on outcomes, not process, not mythical legal jargon that says, ‘somebody's a fiduciary, that must mean they give better advice.’ [Bernie] Madoff was a fiduciary, and he stole from his clients. The legal labels in the process do not guarantee outcomes.”

DOL process is 'wrong'

Cadin also disagrees with the argument that this rule has been a long time coming. While he accepts work began on it more than 13 years ago, he says the world has “dramatically shifted” given that the first iteration was withdrawn, the second was vacated by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, and Regulation Best Interest was subsequently adopted by the SEC. The latter process, he says, in contrast to the new rule, was “very American”, took in a lot of stakeholder input and “explicitly rejected a fiduciary only approach.”

“The reason why I feel so strongly that [the Retirement Security Rule] process is unAmerican, and I’m abashed about that, is that from the beginning, you have a handful of unelected bureaucrats at the Department of Labor foisting their predetermined worldview on to the American people. They believe they know best.”

Having testified before the DOL and met with them on half-a-dozen occasions, Cadin expressed disappointment in its failure to at any time ask him why Finseca and its members believe what it believes. “That is unAmerican, that's not how our system of government is set up,” he says. “It's not how the process should work, and it's wrong, and the results will be millions of Americans will lose access to financial advice and they will have less access to the products they need.”

Latest News

SEC Says Game Service Roblox Part of ‘Active Investigation’
SEC Says Game Service Roblox Part of ‘Active Investigation’

Short sellers previously said the company was under investigation, though Roblox denied allegations.

Musk’s DOGE descends on CFPB with intention to shut it down
Musk’s DOGE descends on CFPB with intention to shut it down

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is in the crosshairs of the Republican group that is widely attempting to dismantle government agencies.

Advisor fighting Finra banishment loses $17.7 million dispute with old firm
Advisor fighting Finra banishment loses $17.7 million dispute with old firm

National Securities Corp. sued the advisor in 2020, alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment.

Job numbers, inflation leaving room for Fed to hold rates
Job numbers, inflation leaving room for Fed to hold rates

Recent data support a measured pace by the Federal Reserve for the year ahead.

Private assets remain hot despite surging stock market
Private assets remain hot despite surging stock market

Financial advisors are still adding alternatives despite the surge in publicly traded stock prices

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.

SPONSORED Why wealth advisors should care about the future of federal tax policy

Blue Vault features expert strategies to harness for maximum client advantage.