A contemplation of Regulation BI

A contemplation of Regulation BI
The brokerage industry, which has a reputation for not always quietly abiding to external forces, has remained curiously silent on the impending changes
MAY 31, 2020

“In contrast to that commotion over the [Department of Labor] rule, it’s been mostly crickets from the brokerage industry when it comes to firms announcing concrete changes they are making … in preparation for Reg BI.”

The above excerpt from this week’s cover story on Regulation Best Interest by Mark Schoeff Jr. underscores the industry’s reaction to the new rule. The similarities between the hue and cry that accompanied the DOL’s fiduciary rule and the pending judicial decision around Reg BI stand out to me.

The reaction is intriguing because this industry’s reputation does not include quietly abiding the intrusion of external forces. As one source in the article suggests, perhaps it’s semantics because “fiduciary” (the ‘F’ word) feels weightier than “Best Interest.” Plus, the implementation guidance of “good faith effort” and “reasonable progress” leave lots of gray area.

But the second issue may well be the reason for the crickets. A hearing Tuesday will determine if the Securities and Exchange Commission exceeded its authority and ignored Dodd-Frank, so perhaps the relative quiet indicates a delay is more likely than the scheduled June 30 implementation.

Ultimately, does strict regulation create a greater burden than best-efforts guidance? Watching the implementation across the industry will answer that intriguing question.

Latest News

Wells Fargo nabs $1.7B RBC advisor team, loses two teams to LPL
Wells Fargo nabs $1.7B RBC advisor team, loses two teams to LPL

The advisors on the move include two brothers leading a family practice in Connecticut, and a husband-and-wife tandem working with business owners in the West Coast.

Most potential business successors think there's a plan – but owners say otherwise
Most potential business successors think there's a plan – but owners say otherwise

Business owners and their heirs may be making assumptions instead of having conversations, creating challenges for succession planning, according to new research.

Mariner adds caregiving support as advisors flag rising client need
Mariner adds caregiving support as advisors flag rising client need

The Kansas-based mega-RIA is giving clients access to dedicated care coaches as new surveys show caregiving duties are straining Americans' finances.

Aspen Standard Wealth adds $1.3B in eighth RIA deal
Aspen Standard Wealth adds $1.3B in eighth RIA deal

Aspen's affiliated RIAs now manage $15 billion after the New York-based platform added Kalamazoo-based CWS Financial Advisors.

Hightower Signature Wealth adds $5 billion in deal hat trick
Hightower Signature Wealth adds $5 billion in deal hat trick

The Chicago-based mega-RIA's latest additions, spanning six office locations and over 40 team members, pushes its W-2 platform assets to roughly $35 billion.

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income

SPONSORED Why direct indexing stopped being optional

Direct indexing is on pace to outgrow ETFs and mutual funds. Northern Trust's Ken Lassner explains why the advisors who get it wish they had started sooner.