A contemplation of Regulation BI

A contemplation of Regulation BI
The brokerage industry, which has a reputation for not always quietly abiding to external forces, has remained curiously silent on the impending changes
MAY 31, 2020

“In contrast to that commotion over the [Department of Labor] rule, it’s been mostly crickets from the brokerage industry when it comes to firms announcing concrete changes they are making … in preparation for Reg BI.”

The above excerpt from this week’s cover story on Regulation Best Interest by Mark Schoeff Jr. underscores the industry’s reaction to the new rule. The similarities between the hue and cry that accompanied the DOL’s fiduciary rule and the pending judicial decision around Reg BI stand out to me.

The reaction is intriguing because this industry’s reputation does not include quietly abiding the intrusion of external forces. As one source in the article suggests, perhaps it’s semantics because “fiduciary” (the ‘F’ word) feels weightier than “Best Interest.” Plus, the implementation guidance of “good faith effort” and “reasonable progress” leave lots of gray area.

But the second issue may well be the reason for the crickets. A hearing Tuesday will determine if the Securities and Exchange Commission exceeded its authority and ignored Dodd-Frank, so perhaps the relative quiet indicates a delay is more likely than the scheduled June 30 implementation.

Ultimately, does strict regulation create a greater burden than best-efforts guidance? Watching the implementation across the industry will answer that intriguing question.

Latest News

Advisor moves: UBS pries Merrill veteran loose as LPL adds $200M duo
Advisor moves: UBS pries Merrill veteran loose as LPL adds $200M duo

Raymond James lures a $125M Merrill Lynch advisor in Charlotte while a Stifel pair breaks away to go independent in Southern Oregon

People moves: Crestwood Advisors taps Morgan Stanley veteran as CIO
People moves: Crestwood Advisors taps Morgan Stanley veteran as CIO

Pave Finance, DPL Financial Partners and Gottfried & Somberg also add senior leaders as RIAs and wealthtech firms deepen their benches

Slice on purpose
Slice on purpose

What the feud between “twin” index funds teaches thematic investors

RIAs flag AI risk in Form ADV more often than they admit using AI
RIAs flag AI risk in Form ADV more often than they admit using AI

RIAs flag AI risk in Form ADV more often than they admit using AI

SEC sues eight fake advisor firms over $37m rotating crypto scheme
SEC sues eight fake advisor firms over $37m rotating crypto scheme

Fake advisors, fake platforms, fake crypto - all on a six-month timer

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.