Merrill pays second settlement to former Miami Dolphins player, client of ex-broker

Merrill pays second settlement to former Miami Dolphins player, client of ex-broker
Professional athletes are often targets of scam artists and are particularly vulnerable to fraud.
MAY 15, 2026

Merrill Lynch is continuing to pay large settlements to customers of its former broker, Isaiah T. Williams, whose clients included players of the Miami Dolphins.

In April, Merrill Lynch reached a settlement for $1.25 million with a former Williams client, according to his BrokerCheck profile.

Though not named on the BrokerCheck report, industry sources said the client was Sean Smith, a former NFL defensive back who played with the Dolphins for four seasons through 2012 and then retired five season later.

A Merrill Lynch spokesperson declined to comment.

Professional athletes, particularly football players, are often targets of scam artists. They are vulnerable to fraud because of their short careers, high potential annual salaries, lack of financial expertise and the fact that their families often depend on them as breadwinners.

Smith originally claimed $3.5 million in damages. In his complaint, he alleged that Williams “failed to act in his best interest and recommended an unsuitable asset allocation strategy,” according to BrokerCheck.

It’s at least the second settlement between Merrill Lynch and a professional athlete client of Williams.

In August former Dolphins Pro Bowl defensive back, Reshad Jones, received a $9.5 million settlement from Merrill Lynch, where Williams  worked before being arrested and charged last summer this summer for criminal activities, including grand theft, fraud and money laundering. 

Williams worked at Merrill Lynch in Boca Raton, Fla., from 2017 to the end of last year, according to his BrokerCheck profile, when he voluntarily resigned from the firm in the wake of allegations of “conduct involving misappropriation, unsuitable asset allocation, misrepresentations and an improper outside business activity.”

Jones originally claimed $16 million in damages, alleging the same charges Merrill Lynch listed in Williams’ resignation. 

 Williams was arrested in Florida last June for his alleged involvement in the theft of almost $2.6 million from Jones, a former Miami Dolphins safety.

Williams allegedly used the stolen funds for numerous personal expenses, according to police and court records, including airline tickets and hotels for himself and women he was dating, car rentals, night clubs and strip clubs. He also allegedly used the stolen funds for child support payments, legal fees, rent, designer clothing and jewelry.

Williams was Jones' financial advisor from January 2022 to March 2024 and allegedly stole $1.6 million from Jones' Bank of America account in more than 130 transactions, according to police and court records.

Jones played safety for the Miami Dolphins in 128 games from 2010 to 2019, making the Pro-Bowl twice.

Latest News

Atlanta B-D Arkadios Capital pays $500K to settle investor lawsuit involving former broker.
Atlanta B-D Arkadios Capital pays $500K to settle investor lawsuit involving former broker.

Jim Walesa worked in the securities industry for 39 years before leaving in 2021.

A tale of two consumers: The growing divide between Wall Street and Main Street
A tale of two consumers: The growing divide between Wall Street and Main Street

As the market turned from pricing in cuts to betting on hikes this year, the developing reality of a K-shaped economy has real implications for households and investors alike.

People moves: XYPN president Vince Hockett to retire in 2027
People moves: XYPN president Vince Hockett to retire in 2027

Also, SEI names LPL’s Kristie Edling-Day as CIO, TD Bank U.S. taps Hardeep Walia to lead wealth, and BMO adds an Illinois regional president

Family offices poured $68.3B into AI and RIA deals in Q3 2026
Family offices poured $68.3B into AI and RIA deals in Q3 2026

FINTRX data shows 342 company transactions in the quarter, with wealth management consolidation driving nearly one in seven deals.

Wells Fargo and Merrill Lynch settle excessive commissions probe
Wells Fargo and Merrill Lynch settle excessive commissions probe

State regulators secure $4.4 million from two broker-dealers over unreasonable charges on small-dollar retail equity trades.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.

SPONSORED In the Age of AI, Trust Becomes the Advisor's Greatest Asset

As AI makes financial information more accessible than ever, Lana Hock explains why human judgment, trust, and empathy remain the qualities clients value most in a financial advisor