The SEC chose the lightest available sanction for a former sales agent who sold unregistered securities - over its own enforcement arm’s objections.
The Securities and Exchange Commission on November 13 censured a former sales agent at Pacific West Capital Group for selling unregistered securities and acting as an unregistered broker. But the Commission turned down its own Division of Enforcement, which had pushed for a full industry bar.
The decision capped a long-running enforcement case. The SEC first sued Cannon and others in April 2015 in the US District Court for the Central District of California. The agency alleged that from 2011 through November 2014, he sold unregistered life settlement interests and operated as an unregistered broker while working as a sales agent for Pacific West.
Pacific West, according to the SEC’s opinion, ran a sizable operation. Through Cannon and other sales agents, it solicited investors in life settlement interests, which the district court found to be securities. Agents made pitches at investor seminars, handed out sales materials, fielded questions, closed deals through purchase agreements, and collected commissions. In total, Pacific West effected sales to more than 3,000 investors.
In April 2023, the district court granted partial summary judgment for the SEC, finding Cannon had violated the registration provisions in Securities Act Section 5(a) and (c) and Exchange Act Section 15(a). The court permanently enjoined him from future violations and ordered $15,000 in tier one civil penalties and $219,333.33 in disgorgement. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed.
The Division of Enforcement then launched a follow-on administrative proceeding under Exchange Act Section 15(b), seeking associational and penny stock bars. Cannon fought back on two fronts: that the proceeding violated his due process rights because it forced him before the same body that had just prosecuted him in federal court, and that the doctrine of res judicata should block it because the SEC could have sought conduct-restricting relief in the original case.
The Commission rejected both arguments. On due process, it relied on the Supreme Court’s holding in Withrow v. Larkin that an agency can both prosecute and adjudicate without violating due process. On res judicata, the Commission pointed to Exchange Act Section 15(b), which requires a prior court injunction as a predicate for follow-on proceedings - meaning Congress designed the system to allow exactly this kind of two-step enforcement.
When it came to the sanction, though, the Commission pulled back. It found that Cannon’s misconduct was “serious and recurrent” and noted he had told the district court he wanted to continue working in the securities industry as an investment adviser - a factor that pointed toward some restriction on his activities.
The turning point: the district court had found no scienter. Cannon, the court concluded, “could reasonably have believed” the life settlement interests were exempt from registration, given the close legal question involved. The Commission credited his assurances against future violations and his recognition of wrongfulness.
A censure - described in prior case law as “the lightest administrative sanction available” - was enough, the Commission decided. The order was issued under Chairman Atkins and Commissioner Uyeda.
For compliance professionals and RIA principals, the decision is a reminder that the SEC will pursue follow-on administrative proceedings after winning in federal court, and that due process and res judicata defenses have limited traction in that context. But it also shows the Commission is willing to calibrate sanctions to the facts - particularly where the underlying conduct lacked scienter.
Independent advisors in Colorado, Texas and Arkansas join larger wealth management platforms through acquisitions and partnerships
Welch brothers’ 93 Financial Group gives the Osaic-owned RIA a fifth greater Boston office, days after a $1.6B triple acquisition
The hedge fund group allegedly held a financing 'vice grip' over the company
New wealth, evolving donor expectations, and responsible AI are reshaping charitable planning for advisors.
Bridge Operating Partners debuts with deep industry pedigree and a proprietary AI system designed to sharpen decision-making for wealth firm executives.
Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives
Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.